Trade Evaluation

[Solsombra]

All things being equal and irrespective of roster needs who is getting the better deal here?

Player A- gets Leftwich and Deangelo Williams
Player B- gets Hasselbeck and Mike Anderson

Please respond, this is just a newbie making sure he's not getting ripped off!

[WaCougMBS]

Seems like a kind of do nothing offer to me. A downgrade at one pos to upgrade at the other. Unless this really fits your needs (no matter which side you are), I say stay put for now.

Some help?
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/foru ... p?t=263454

[Solsombra]

Thanks for the reply, I just wanted to check that it was close enough that I wasn't getting duped. I am Player B btw, and in desperate need of a QB.

[Solsombra]

Getting worried by the poll results coming through. Would it be more even if I kept Leftwich and offered Plummer and DeAngelo Williams instead?

[prricci]

The trade is fair...but the upside of Williams is making more people ( I speculate as that is why I chose A) say they would rather be A.



Help

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/foru ... p?t=263508

[scotth36]

I was offered Reggie Wayne for my 2010 1st Round pick and 2010 2nd Round pick (roughly be between pick 9 and 13). We have 14 teams IDP (1-QB, 2-RB, 3-WR, 1-TE, 1-PK, 1-DT, 2-DE, 4-LB, 2-CB, 2-S).

[z raptor]

The trade is fair...but the upside of Williams is making more people ( I speculate as that is why I chose A) say they would rather be A.



Help

viewtopic.php?t=263508

Couldn't have said it better!!!

[z raptor]

I was offered Reggie Wayne for my 2010 1st Round pick and 2010 2nd Round pick (roughly be between pick 9 and 13). We have 14 teams IDP (1-QB, 2-RB, 3-WR, 1-TE, 1-PK, 1-DT, 2-DE, 4-LB, 2-CB, 2-S).

I'd do it.......you could always trade for 2010 picks later......