Top 10 RB's ??

[Omaha Red Sox]

why does a bunch of people have Dunn in the top 10... he's has not impressed. I think Gore >> Dunn at this point.

I agree with Omaha. He's the 2nd leading rusher in the NFL so far and only behind by 1 yard. What do you mean he hasn't impressed?

If that's the case, why haven't more people listed McGahee? Who actually is leading the league in rushing at this point. Touchdowns can't be the issue, neither has any yet.

I think only one person even listed Willis so far. I think arguments could be made for him being up there now, especially if the O-line play continues to be solid.

dunn is playing in a better offense than mcgahee

That and Dunn's done it a whole season before. McGahee disappeared most of last season. If he keeps it up, of course he deserves a mention.

[BrutallyHuge]

dunn is playing in a better offense than mcgahee

Losman > Vick
Evans > ??? Who is it? Jenkins? White? Lelie? All Scrubs.
McGahee > Dunn

[BigMusky]

dunn is playing in a better offense than mcgahee

Losman > Vick
Evans > ??? Who is it? Jenkins? White? Lelie? All Scrubs.
McGahee > Dunn

to quote a great man "you forgot to add sense to your post"

[jmog]

dunn is playing in a better offense than mcgahee

Losman > Vick
Evans > ??? Who is it? Jenkins? White? Lelie? All Scrubs.
McGahee > Dunn

ATL's offensive line>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>BUFs offensive line

Theres the difference.

You also forgot to mention TEs, I'd rather have Alge Crumpler than Evans.

Also, sorry, Losman<Vick, and I don't even like Vick.

[superslugger616]

dunn is playing in a better offense than mcgahee

Losman > Vick
Evans > ??? Who is it? Jenkins? White? Lelie? All Scrubs.
McGahee > Dunn

to quote a great man "you forgot to add sense to your post"

vick is better than losman
crumpler is better than evans
the atl o-line is better than buffalo's
atl's defense is better, whereas buffalo will be playing from behind more often

[slacker317]

I'll copy my post from another identical thread from another forum here. Except it's top 25:

1. LaDainian Tomlinson
2. Larry Johnson
3. Clinton Portis
4. Brian Westbrook
5. Tiki Barber
6. Rudi Johnson
7. Steven Jackson
8. Chester Taylor
9. Frank Gore
10. Willie Parker
11. Shaun Alexander
12. Ronnie Brown
13. Julius Jones
14. Tatum Bell
15. Edgerrin James
16. Ahman Green
17. Kevin Jones
18. Fred Taylor
19. Reggie Bush
20. Willis McGahee
21. Jamal Lewis
22. Cadillac Williams
23. Thomas Jones
24. Lawrence Maroney
25. Deuce McAllister

edit: it's best not to ask for explanations. I wrote it a couple of days ago while and don't quite remember the exact reasons why I placed a few of those in their spots.

[SwiperNoSwiping]

dunn is playing in a better offense than mcgahee

Losman > Vick
Evans > ??? Who is it? Jenkins? White? Lelie? All Scrubs.
McGahee > Dunn

to quote a great man "you forgot to add sense to your post"

vick is better than losman
crumpler is better than evans
the atl o-line is better than buffalo's
atl's defense is better, whereas buffalo will be playing from behind more often

Well all those seem to point toward Atlanta as a team being better than Buffalo, not Dunn vs. McGahee. Those might make you tend to think Dunn should be running away with the rushing title. But he isn't. Granted, yes...It's one yard. All I am saying is perhaps Willis should be given a bit more credit for how well he's playing DESPITE all those factors.

[darb48824]

Mcgahee has ONE touchdown in the last TWELVE Games that should keep him out of top 15. That is one hell of a stretch. I wouldnt touch him with a ten foot pole

[SwiperNoSwiping]

Mcgahee has ONE touchdown in the last TWELVE Games that should keep him out of top 15. That is one hell of a stretch. I wouldnt touch him with a ten foot pole

I wouldn't exactly be bragging about Dunn's 3 in the last 19 games. Duckett being part of the equation is a moot point, that hasn't gotten Dunn into the endzone anymore this year so far.

[superslugger616]

I'll copy my post from another identical thread from another forum here. Except it's top 25:

1. LaDainian Tomlinson
2. Larry Johnson
3. Clinton Portis
4. Brian Westbrook
5. Tiki Barber
6. Rudi Johnson
7. Steven Jackson
8. Chester Taylor
9. Frank Gore
10. Willie Parker
11. Shaun Alexander
12. Ronnie Brown
13. Julius Jones
14. Tatum Bell
15. Edgerrin James
16. Ahman Green
17. Kevin Jones
18. Fred Taylor
19. Reggie Bush
20. Willis McGahee
21. Jamal Lewis
22. Cadillac Williams
23. Thomas Jones
24. Lawrence Maroney
25. Deuce McAllister

edit: it's best not to ask for explanations. I wrote it a couple of days ago while and don't quite remember the exact reasons why I placed a few of those in their spots.

i think chester taylor at 8 is a bit high
portis at 3: do u own him?
im not sure about julius jones above edge
mcgahee can move up a bit
dunn not in top 25????