Who will have the better NFL career... Maroney or Addai?

[Villanova1985]

Who do you guys think will have the better career? I personally think Addai... he has a better ofensive line, surrounding cast, and Peyton Manning. He will be moving into a state of the art stadium in two years and he has more speed and power than maroney but he is not as shifty. In my opinion Addai has more romm to improve than Maroney who is arguably a little better now. This is my input... lets here what you guys think.

[steelerfan513]

i gotta go with the guy performing well right now with maroney. he has put up great stats while splitting carries with corey dillon, and the pats are a running team even with tom brady at quarterback. i havent bought into addai as a great running back, and the colts will always pass a lot with peyton there.

[SniperShot]

Man this is like the hardest ever question to answer. I think career will be Addai. But for this year at least it's all about Maroney. I think Addai will win a super bowl first though. *knock on wood*

[TheRawDAWG]

Funny, I looked at this post and thought "are you kidding me?" Maroney will have the better year, the better career and maybe be the best back out of the draft.

In all honesty I think Williams, Bush AND Maroney will have better careers than Addai.

And back to Maroney and Addai for a second. And I'll admit I don't watch alot of Colts games or Pats games. But I've watched about the same amount of time for both teams this year. And to say Addai has more power is borderline ridiculous to me. I haven't seen Addai tossing guys off him while barely losing speed. And I also see Maroney hitting the edge alot quicker as well. Maybe Addai can run faster in a 40 but it looks to me like Maroney is the one with better football speed and more power on the football field. Just me though. But I don't think this one is even close.

[skinsfan]

Maroney will, but he won't be one of the "greats" because he'll get his knee blown out before his fourth season and never return to his form.