BUF/HOU or IND/TB comeback game your pick

[Clevelander]

which game do you think was the best...
comebacks like these don't happen often but was glad to be able to see both. i hope most remember the bills comeback....

[Mean Machine]

Monday night miracle, Jets over Dolphins.

[Free Bagel]

Monday night miracle, Jets over Dolphins.

Never happened.

[thefonze]

In all honesty, in my opinion their are so equal I can't pick one. The COlts vs. Bucs is fresh in my mind the Bills Oilers was what 11 years ago... can't be objective. Two of the best all time games ever though.

[zombiez]

I cant beleive this vote is even 50/50........the Bills did it with a back up QB........and in the Playoffs.....thats like compareing apples to oranges

[kid a]

I cant beleive this vote is even 50/50........the Bills did it with a back up QB........and in the Playoffs.....thats like compareing apples to oranges

Yeah, and the Bills also spent over a quarter and a half orchestrating their comeback. Peyton Manning did it in 4 minutes. 4 MINUTES!!!! Not the playoffs, but national TV, Monday Night, with an undefeated season on the line, against the Super Bowl Champs!

The Oilers/Bills was the 2nd greatest game I ever watched. Monday Night was #1.

[LBJackal]

I voted for the Colts/Bucs too. Partly because I don't remember the Bills/Oilers (I DO remember the Bills being ridiculed heavily for all the SB losses tho ), and partly because the Colts' comeback seems untouchable in terms of "best of all time". I will reiterate some of what kid a said, but here is why it's #1 in my opinion:

-It was Monday Night Football, everybody was watching
-Tony Dungy was facing his former team, who fired him 2 seasons ago
-Key questioned Marvin's ability as a WR earlier in the game, and Marvin got the last laugh
-The Bucs have the undisputed best defense in recent memory
-The Colts scored 3 TD's against them within a span of 2 minutes and 40 seconds to tie the game
-Vandy, the most accurate kicker in NFL history, got two tries to kick a chip shot IN OVERTIME and nearly missed them both

All these things add up to the best & most entertaining comeback in NFL history IMO. Maybe if I was older (I'm only 19) I would consider the Bills/Oilers more, but I'm not, so Colts/Bucs it is!

[Houston Native]

I says the colts/bucs game is the better one, mainly because i've blocked the other game from my memory

[M_Zimm_ffc]

I cant beleive this vote is even 50/50........the Bills did it with a back up QB........and in the Playoffs.....thats like compareing apples to oranges

Yeah, and the Bills also spent over a quarter and a half orchestrating their comeback. Peyton Manning did it in 4 minutes. 4 MINUTES!!!! Not the playoffs, but national TV, Monday Night, with an undefeated season on the line, against the Super Bowl Champs!

The Oilers/Bills was the 2nd greatest game I ever watched. Monday Night was #1.

For some reason, I always agree with kid a...