Week 7 GC: PHI @ TB

[Amazinz]

It missed the tying the record by 1 yard. Pretty impressive.

[RyanTB]

Well maybe it's just that Ronde Barber is THAT GOOD and it really has nothing to do with Mcsnabb.

[eaglesrule]

roind ebarber is fantastic. two great plays. that wasn't mcnabb screwing up per se, both were awesome plays.

[beanoX3]

i don't think you can add rawdawg.


last time I checked, 14 is less than 21. Mcnabb accounted for 21 points, three td's. he erased the damge he did.

The difference between beldsoe and mcnabb is that yes, the ints were no one's fault byut his, and weren't luck.

the difference being is he made amends for that and gave the eagles the lead.

since the eagles were leading with 30 seconds left, because of him, its not his fault.

to say anything else is patently idiotic. you just like ragging on the eagles. I hate the boys too, but you need to at least apply some logic.

Hehe, read through some of this thread and it is pretty amusing.

Arguing whether or not the loss was McNabb's fault is an argument that has no end. Circular logic, chicken or the egg type of argument.

I just like how McNabb threw up. Totally unexpected. But hey, the Raiders won!! LOL!!

[SniperShot]

I knew it was a windy day. Some of the kickoffs for TB went out of the endzone when they were kicking that way. But make a 62 yarder... That was totally insane. So awesome for the Bucs.

[RyanTB]

I knew it was a windy day. Some of the kickoffs for TB went out of the endzone when they were kicking that way. But make a 62 yarder... That was totally insane. So awesome for the Bucs.

It wasn't windy at my house at all and I am in Tampa. Strange.

[mrblitz]

Damn! Couldn't believe what i saw watching Bryant kick that 62 yarder really put a dagger in me. Unbelievable.

[TheRawDAWG]

i don't think you can add rawdawg.


last time I checked, 14 is less than 21. Mcnabb accounted for 21 points, three td's. he erased the damge he did.

The difference between beldsoe and mcnabb is that yes, the ints were no one's fault byut his, and weren't luck.

the difference being is he made amends for that and gave the eagles the lead.

since the eagles were leading with 30 seconds left, because of him, its not his fault.

to say anything else is patently idiotic. you just like ragging on the eagles. I hate the boys too, but you need to at least apply some logic.

ROTFLMAO!!! You're talking to me about logic and math?

The point that you are bringing up about McNabb only accounting for 14 points for the Bucs and he accounted for 21 with the Eagles is a joke. A QB shjouldn't count for any points against his team. Especially not 14. What makes it worse is the fact the Bucs couldn't move the ball against the Eagles D. If not for McNabb the Eagles win this game. They didn't because he spotted them 14 points. And btw, how do you count a dump off Westbrook takes to the house as McNabb's 7 points. Just cause he made a dump off pass doesn't mean he should get the credit. I mean if Westy rushed it would that still count for McNabb too? I know it count for him the books. But come on.

But back to the original point. McNabb account for 21 points doesn't make up for the fact he gave them 14 and they won because of those 14. That kick means nothing if McNabb doesn't spot them the 14 points.

[nadyhin]

i still say
westbrook shudve walked up n down the goal line
wen he had that 50 yard run

[buffalobillsrul2002]

i still say
westbrook shudve walked up n down the goal line
wen he had that 50 yard run

Interesting thought...he slowed down too, maybe he should've waited for some TB guys, then went into the endzone. HOwever, I don't know if somebody might consider that showoff/unethical....

And as for the argument about McNabb winning/losing the game, I will say this. The Tampa Bay defense, led by Ronde Barber, won that game. Now if you think that means that the Eagles O lost it, fine, same difference basically. Whether or not McNabb lost it or Tampa Bay's defense won it can be argued, but essentially the eagles offense scored 7 points. And Eagles turnovers gave away at least 9 points of their own that they could've scored That's a BAD offensive performance at any level of football...

Too bad for the Eagles' D, they really dominated today but still found a way to lose the football game...