Fair trade or not?

[otdna60]

I need to know if this is a far trade because it went down in my league and some people are not happy. I want to ask people on here because ya'll are fair, impartial, and ya know fantasy football.

Team A traded away:

Andre Johnson

Willis McGahee

& Reggie Brown (eagles)

FOR Team B players of:

Greg Jennings (after hurt)

Reggie Williams

& Fred Taylor.

Can anyone tell me if this trade is fair or Just?

Thanks you.

[BrutallyHuge]

I would much rather have McGahee, Andre, and Reggie. I think every player on that side of the table is better.

[SniperShot]

Yup very bad trade. IN no way is Team A getting anything better out of that trade. He is downgrading in every player.

[flotsamnjetsam]

Yup very bad trade. IN no way is Team A getting anything better out of that trade. He is downgrading in every player.

Yep. Horrible trade. Whether it's vetoable or not really depends on the records of the teams. If the team getting AJ/McGahee/Brown is a really good team and the other team sucks, then this could be seen as collusion since as Sniper said, the one team is downgrading at every position. That's one of the worst trades I've seen in a while.

[JordanParfitt]

Terrible... just terrible...

[mysticphysh]

Both managers should be tied to stakes and flogged publically.

Oh, and this is the wrong section for that. Should go in Draft, Trade, Keeper & Waiver Questions or Football Leftovers.