Toss Up: Harrison vs. Wayne

[Favre.com]

Harrison is "technically" the number 1 on the Colts, but Wayne is getting targetted just as much. This week Wayne outplayed Harrison by a wide margin, although I realize Bailey was on Harrison. What do you see out of them for the rest of the season, who would you rather have: Good ol' reliable Marvin or the guy that goes against the second best corners in Wayne?

[killiansjmd]

It's tough because it's going to depend on how each defense will try to defend them. If they are going to continue to double team Harrison then Peyton will keep throwing towards Wayne who likely will be covered one on one. Similiar situation is happening with the Bengals as Cj is being double teamed and TJ Housh and Henry are cashing in/

[chidoy]

touche.

It's like this with Marvin and Wayne. Both are studs and Peyton will always find the open man. Next week Marv will blow up for two td's and 100yds. the next is Wayne, and throw Stokely or whoever else in there. IMHO, can't go wrong with either one. Just like killinasjmd said with the Bengals situation.

[eaglesrule]

its tough. I have both of them in one league, and I am constantly second guessing myself on the question of whether or not I should be divesting myself of one.

I was just offered mcgahee for harrison, and honestly, both indy receivers could put up rb-esque numbers. Granted, not top tier really, but definitely second tier caliber backs. Plus, I might keep them just because I have a key game coming up against the pyeton team, and we could meet in the playoffs.

I really think this is a toss up at this point, you can't tell what defenses will always do, and peyton is just that good.

I'd be happy with one or the other--or in my case, both.

[killiansjmd]

Here are their stats through 8 weeks:


Targets - Wayne 65 Harrison 69
Red Zone Targets - Wayne 13 Harrison 12
Receptions - Wayne 38 Harrison 44
Yards - Wayne 642 Harrison 553
Yds/rec - Wayne 16.9 HArrison 12.6
TD's - Wayne 5 Harrison 3

[codered7]

They gonna be similar this year. Wayne looked better last game, only because the denver #2 cb is terrible. I don't even kno his name, I just kno he sucks in madden... get shitted by mark clayton all day. But I think peyton will pick on matchups, if he likes marvins then he'll go to him, if not he'll go to wayne. Peyton's that great of a qb. He'll find any advantage and exploit it.

If I had both I'd trade harrison for his name value, and keep wayne since he'll get the same stats.

[mrblitz]

I really do think it's a toss up. Just look at both of their game logs. They are really a hit or miss type deal.

[Purple Allegiance]

Impossible to say. I'd lean towards Harrison just because his past production has been better even with Wayne in the fold. I'd love to have either though, normally from week to week they both produce.

[Twisted Sister]

In PPR, I'd keep Harrison.

Just my preference.

[Champagne Supernova]

They gonna be similar this year. Wayne looked better last game, only because the denver #2 cb is terrible. I don't even kno his name, I just kno he sucks in madden... get shitted by mark clayton all day. But I think peyton will pick on matchups, if he likes marvins then he'll go to him, if not he'll go to wayne. Peyton's that great of a qb. He'll find any advantage and exploit it.

If I had both I'd trade harrison for his name value, and keep wayne since he'll get the same stats.

Darrent Williams is a freak in Madden. 97 Speed