Toss Up: Harrison vs. Wayne

[Crippler]

I'd much rather have Harrison. He's more consistant and is more proven. Yes, Wayne had a big game but Harrison is more reliable in my opinion.

[JasonSeahorn]

Be happy if you have one or the other. Both should be good for 6 catches, 80 yards and a touchdown. Hell, you could play both of them on the same team and do fine.

If you had to choose one, i'd choose harrison because most teams DON'T double team him, he won't face a CB like bailey every week, and peyton still looks to him first in the endzone.

[skinsfan]

They're positively equal. Each will have huge games, although of course in the long run, Wayne's the guy to have (keeper). I'd choose Harrison personally because I like him better than Wayne.

[The Jury]

I'd much rather have Harrison. He's more consistant and is more proven. Yes, Wayne had a big game but Harrison is more reliable in my opinion.

Yeah I agree. They will probably put up similar totals by year's end, but Harrison seems to be the reliable, possession receiver, while Wayne is the "big play" guy.

[Joeybagadonuts]

I am a Wayne owner and would MUCH rather have Harrison. Wayne has not been historcaly as good a redzone target, though the numbers this year (inflated by one game) seem to counter that thought.
Harrison is money, I'd take him every time. Though I'm not complaining about Waynes weekend...he gave me my victory.

Thanks Reggie.

[Midway]

Yeah, over the course of a season, Marvin will post better numbers. And the chemistry that Marvin and Peyton have is second to none. Just wait, Marvin will bust out with a huge game before the season is over.

I have both in different leagues, Harrison in a ppr and Wayne in non-ppr, and honestly apart from that huge game last week Wayne had been pretty quiet. Good but not great, while Marvin is the model of consistency, you don't have valleys with Marvin, just good production and a few break out games.

For this season, I'd rather have Marvin. Next year, Wayne may overtake him. They're production has gotten closer and closer each year and you know it's only a matter of time before Wayne becomes the true #1 in Indy. But for this year, Marvin will be the better receiver to have.