Toss Up: McNabb vs Brees

[lmcjaho]

So here's the question - has McNabb's weak schedule to date played such a big role in his performance that those of us who have ridden him to the top of the standings should be worried when he returns from his bye to face a much tougher run, or is he the real deal?

By contrast, Brees put up huge numbers (although he also had a bunch of giveaways) against the stingy Ravens D yesterday, and has had a hot hand to date, averaging over 270 yds/gm and over 1.5 TDs/gm despite a schedule most would say was harder than Philly's...

So who would you say is a better stretch-run QB from here out?

[beanoX3]

I only voted for McNabb because the Eagles have no offense if they don't throw the ball. So he has a greater chance of continuing to throw more TDs than Brees does, IMO.

[BrutallyHuge]

By contrast, Brees put up huge numbers (although he also had a bunch of giveaways) against the stingy Ravens D yesterday

Ravens are only stingy against the run. People can throw all day on them. NO did the same thing...couldn't run at all...chucked all game.