disgruntledjetsfan wrote: his mere presence on the field alters defenses so drastically that I daresay makes him one of the top 5 most valuable players to his team in all of football.
I think he is valuable, but to tell you the truth, I think the Falcons would be much better if Shaub was QB and they used Vick sparingly like Slash or Randle El
I agree. I think that someone in atlanta should get creative and develop a 2 QB set where they have schaub and vick both offset a bit, and you dont know who the snap will go to. Not sure how well this would work, but I think schaub is a better passer, and vick is the better overall athlete, and it could really confuse defenses
And just to interject my opinion, if I was building a football team, I would choose McNabb over vick as my QB any day.
One thing with Vick that i think people need to realize is that while he is a tremendous athlete and brings alot to the table, if the falcons get into a situation where they are down and need to pass alot, Vick is NOT the guy you want back there. He may have the ability to break one and change the game, but he also is more of a risk to lose the game with an int or fumble or something.