Gates vs Winslow..Who wins?

[Dplymkr88]

There is a lot of hate of KW2 because of his mouth. Gates has been a sleeping giant this year and I hope that KW2 has rattled his cage.

[beanoX3]

I don't really hate KW2, but I do think he's a total moron. Why he has to proclaim himself the best TE after playing a grand total of 9 games in 3 years of being in the NFL, he really has no reason to talk trash. I don't mind trash talk between players, but come on Kellen, talk trash AFTER you prove it on the field for at least a year.

These players that make bold statements like this without having proved it in the NFL are total idiots and look pretty foolish.

[jdsun1]

I got winslow in the 10th round of my draft meanwhile gates went 6 rounds higher. Winslow wins. I win.

[FatFoot]

I'd take Gates, Heap, or Crumpler over Winslow.

[BlueBandit24]

Numbers lie. Winslow has every reason to have better numbers since his team and RB's suck. They have to throw, and considering their only weapons are in the passing game, he benefits. If he puts up 1,000 yard, 10+ TD season, maybe he can be in the same breath as Gates. And if we are going on numbers, let's take a look at their numbers since '04, the year Winslow was drafted:

Gates: 202 rec, 2447 yards, 27 TD's

Winslow: 45 rec, 403 yards, 3 TD's

[FatFoot]

That's a really... really... bad argument, dude.

[Double Play Ball]

I think KWII showed today why he is THE BEST TE in the league.
Winslow- 11 REC for 78 yds
Gates- 2 REC for 22 yds

The numbers don't lie

[Matthias]

I think KWII showed today why he is THE BEST TE in the league.
Winslow- 11 REC for 78 yds
Gates- 2 REC for 22 yds

The numbers don't lie

No? Were they targeted on the same passes? Were they running sprints? Did they play in some kind of pre-draft combine today? Because I always thought that numbers equal talent plus opportunity. Or did only one of them play for a team whose running back went for 172 yards?

[flotsamnjetsam]

I think KWII showed today why he is THE BEST TE in the league.
Winslow- 11 REC for 78 yds
Gates- 2 REC for 22 yds

The numbers don't lie

The soldier is the best TE on his team...that's about it.

[Alkaholik]

Yea, well i cant say Winslow didnt show Gates up, but its pretty easy to get more receptions and balls thrown your way when your down the entire 2nd half and go no huddles with only passing and pretty hard to get many passes your way when your up by a bunch and you run the ball all you want.