With those options, I'd stay away from Scheffler. He's been wildly inconsistent this year, with 8 games with zero receptions. Even with Cutler at QB, he has only 4 receptions. He's a nice option for next year, but for this year, there's better choices IMO.
I considered him for one team that is about to begin playoffs as an injury replacement for Ben Watson, but I picked up Vernon Davis instead. He's a similar gamble to Scheffler, but he was targeted much more often last week. And with Eric Johnson out, he's got no one to steal snaps. Scheffler still has Stephen Alexander in front of him, I think.
I believe Alexander is injured, but regardless I agree V. Davis is the better choice. Consider that San Fran gave him the ball on a reverse, it's obvious they want him involved.
Don't evalaute Scheffler just based on his goose-eggs. He was in the dog house for a couple months where he wasn't even active. Hard to get fantasy points when you don't even dress. His chemistry with Cutler was really great in the preseason and reappeared last week. There's a good chance of it continuing. I definitely would start VD over him though.
Heap, Winslow, Vernon Davis are all better starts, in my opinion, than Sheffler. That being said, because of his chemistry with Cutler, i'm sure the broncos will probably be using him...rookies like their security blankets, and Sheffler looks like the guy, so in place of desmond clark or Jerramy stevens, i can see rolling the dice with sheffler for sure. And for next year, i like Sheffler with Cutler throwing to him all year.
shasty mcnasty
Special Teams Staff
Posts: 116
Joined: 29 Mar 2006
Yards this season: 0
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: enjoying another beautiful day in southwest Michigan