Its not even a contest. That botched extra point wins it hands down. No reason to even bring up any competition.
In my league:
Just lost in the semi-finals by 1 1/2 points. I was watching the Jets game, and watched my Superbowl hopes go down the tubes when Cotchery caught that TD pass! The way the game was going, I thought I really had a chance. Steve Smith, giving me a complete blank, has to be the goat of the week for me. Jacksonville, with their great homefield defense comes in a close second.