Who was the best ROOKIE this year?

[Kingctb27]

MJD was great, but you can't discount what Reggie did for that team.

Being a decoy throughout the first 8 or so games helped that team so much, and much of that has gone unnoticed.

I don't care how good Brees has been, Bush has made that team 2 wins better this year.

[BrutallyHuge]

Vince Young

MJD
McNeill
Colston
Maroney
Bush

[Warhawk]

Vince Young

MJD
McNeill
Colston
Maroney
Bush

Again, no Addai, even with Maroney on the list?

[hookem2003]

Fantasy: MJD
Reality: Vince

[deerayfan072]

Well if you go by the NFL looks like

Vince Young Offensive Rookie of the year

Demarco Ryans Defensive Rookie of the year

[The_Dude]

I like Vince Young for ROY. I know MJD and Colston and Bush all put up great numbers for us fantasy footballers but what Vince did with the Titans was amazing. He carried that team on his back throughout the season. Without Vince i could easily see the that team winning less than 3 games.

As much of a Young doubter (hater) I was, I think Young walks away easily with this award. This was a strong rookie class, but Young turned the Titans' season around.

[moose162]

Fantasy: MJD
Reality: Vince

absolutely. Young easily wins the ROY award. I think it's amazing how many people in this thread believe Jones-Drew should win. I figure it's all his fantasy owners

[deerayfan072]

I like Vince Young for ROY. I know MJD and Colston and Bush all put up great numbers for us fantasy footballers but what Vince did with the Titans was amazing. He carried that team on his back throughout the season. Without Vince i could easily see the that team winning less than 3 games.

As much of a Young doubter (hater) I was, I think Young walks away easily with this award. This was a strong rookie class, but Young turned the Titans' season around.

he already won it

[RocketsDWM]

Vince won Should have been MJD or Colston.

[GreatestShowOnEarth]

Vince won Should have been MJD or Colston.

Why?