You might have guessed it was Mike Lodish who played in four Super Bowls with Buffalo and two with Denver. However, we're looking for appearances, not actual game play. WR, Don Beebe also appeared in six Super Bowls, though he only received playing time in four. Beebe was with Buffalo for their Super Bowls XXV through XXVIII and with the Packers in XXI and XXII. However, Beebe didn't play in either Super Bowl XXV and Super Bowl XXXII.