Carson Palmer/Brady or Marc Bulger/Mcnabb

[codered7]

Which of these qbs is the best value?

Palmer, Brady-2nd roundish
-Palmers gonna blow up this year...great fantasy playoff schedule as well
-Brady.. look at his wides, but his schedule is not as appealing(toolbox got 22nd worst for fantasy playoffs)

Bulger, Mcnabb-4th roundish??(thats where he went in my 1st mock)
-I think Bulger gonna blow up as well...contract year, great arsenal, sjax good recep back
-o yea Mcnabb was the best qb before he died...(and his playoff schedule is amazing(ranked #2))

I say draft palmer if he falls to 3rd(I really think u have to draft 2rbs in the first 2 rounds this year), and if he doesn't... dont worry, get bulger or mcnabb in the 4th

What you guys think?

[mystykoekaki]

Keep an eye on McNabb.

[chidoy]

IMHO Bulger / McNabb, McNabb would have easily blown everyone away if not injured. In my league Bulger finished top 5 overall. I agree with your RB's strategy so definitly Bulger / McNabb if available 3rd-4th. Good luck!

[bravesfan42]

I'd rather take Bulger or Mcnabb a little later...although, I'm sure plenty of people have Bulger ranked ahead of Brady. Me being one of them.

[GOD]

Always wait on a Qb. Take Bulger or Mcnabb!

[Kensat30]

I'll take McNabb and Bulger sometime around the 5th or 6th round at the earliest. If they're not there, I'm happy to take Kitna/Romo sometime around the 8th or 9th.

[jackseven]

I had Bulger last year and he killed me with inconsistancy. He put up horrible games against SF and Arizona when I really needed him. I'd take any of the other three before I grab him.

[chidoy]

I had Bulger last year and he killed me with inconsistancy. He put up horrible games against SF and Arizona when I really needed him. I'd take any of the other three before I grab him.

4053 yds. 23 TD's and 8 ints? SUre he didn't do well vs. SF but
Vs. Ari:
21/31 309 yds. Td
27/45 341 2tds. 3int (ouch)

To each their own

[Munboy]

If you can get a player who puts up numbers like Bulger or a healthy McNabb 2 rounds after Plamer or Brady, that's great value. Barring any injuries across the board, all 4 QB's number should be very simular. I think Brady will have his best year yet, considering what he's done in the past with so-so receivers. Now that he has 2 legit deep threats and a WR who can get it done from the slot, he should just go nuts. Palmer will be hurt by the absence of Chris Henry though.

I'd rank these 4 guys as...

Brady
Palmer
Bulger
McNabb (I'm really worried about his injury)

If it were me and I picked up 2 RBs i'm comfortable with in the first two rounds, I'd go for Brady if he's there in the 3rd. If not, I'd size up the players available at that time and then go for Bulger in the next couple rounds.

[jackseven]

I had Bulger last year and he killed me with inconsistancy. He put up horrible games against SF and Arizona when I really needed him. I'd take any of the other three before I grab him.

4053 yds. 23 TD's and 8 ints? SUre he didn't do well vs. SF but
Vs. Ari:
21/31 309 yds. Td
27/45 341 2tds. 3int (ouch)

To each their own

Good posting. I must be thinking of another performance.