There are legit reasons why some people drop out. If they didnt actually have any, and not you assume they didnt have any because you dont know either way, rather they are still quite active in some leagues and have just begun ignoring other leagues, then they definitely deserve to be blacklisted. Banned is a bit harsh, because there's no way for a site admin to know which side is telling the truth. Something similar to what is done with PBCs would work well though.
Okay... sounds good to me. If those owners have signed on to do other stuff, or continue to post on the Cafe, while ignoring their long overdue drafting.... isn't that enough proof... while also ignoring numerous Cafe PMs from league members too?
Anyway, if I was talking about newbies, I wouldn't be posting this.
Maybe we need an anual dropout 2nd week league here on the Cafe to support those of us who are hosed by Cafe members who hose us?