Advice on a trade approval

[Toro]

I have some chatter protesting a trade in one of my keeper leagues. Its Calvin Johnson for Travis Henry. I'm inclined to put it through, But some owners are upset about it, and some are ok with the trade. So far split down the middle. What is your thoughts. I would put it through as Johnson as high ceiling in keeper league and Henry has strong value currently this season. Is this trade equitable?

Thanks

[dream_017]

I have some chatter protesting a trade in one of my keeper leagues. Its Calvin Johnson for Travis Henry. I'm inclined to put it through, But some owners are upset about it, and some are ok with the trade. So far split down the middle. What is your thoughts. I would put it through as Johnson as high ceiling in keeper league and Henry has strong value currently this season. Is this trade equitable?

Thanks

There is no issue with this trade and by the way that teams are split I would say that justifies it.

[Cards24]

I have some chatter protesting a trade in one of my keeper leagues. Its Calvin Johnson for Travis Henry. I'm inclined to put it through, But some owners are upset about it, and some are ok with the trade. So far split down the middle. What is your thoughts. I would put it through as Johnson as high ceiling in keeper league and Henry has strong value currently this season. Is this trade equitable?

Thanks

There is no issue with this trade and by the way that teams are split I would say that justifies it.

Agree...

[dgan]

My guess is the guy getting Henry thinks he has a good chance to win this year. Henry has a couple good years left in him and has the potential to be a top 5 back this year and next. CJ is at LEAST a year away from being good, much less great. So the guy acquiring him is obviously setting up for long term. In a redraft league, Henry is a ton more valuable than CJ. In a keeper league, CJ is much more valuable than Henry. But in a keeper league, if you're always setting up your team for 3 years from now, you'll always be 3 years away from winning. Eventually, you need to either keep those prospects or trade them for big short term gains.

I fail to see any problem with this trade at all.