Trade: Clinton Portis for Troy Brown and Warrick Dunn

[Chicago]

The trade is I give Clinton Portis and receive Troy Brown and Warrick Dunn.

Here is my roster:

QB Fiedler, Jay
QB Brunell, Mark
WR Brown, Tim
WR Chambers, Chris
RB Tomlinson, LaDainian
RB James, Edgerrin
TE Wycheck, Frank
Bench Couch, Tim
Bench Heap, Todd
Bench Stewart, Kordell
Bench Portis, Clinton
Bench Gaffney, Jabar

I think it's an odd trade because I wouldn't start any of the people involved in the trade. I know all about the possibilities and the unsurety of Clinton Portis, but what do you guys know about Troy Brown and Warrick Dunn, and should I make this trade. If so, keep in mind I'd need to drop one player. Who would you drop?

[Destroyrs]

On first glance I would not make that trade. Your WR depth is fine.

If you are in a keeper league, the potential of Portis is much higher. Your QB situation seems to be your weak spot to me. Kordell may get you more than Brunell especially if Smith doesn't report.

You may wish to look at moving one of your QB's with Portis for a better QB.

[SolarfluX]

The trade is I give Clinton Portis and receive Troy Brown and Warrick Dunn.

Here is my roster:

QB Fiedler, Jay
QB Brunell, Mark
WR Brown, Tim
WR Chambers, Chris
RB Tomlinson, LaDainian
RB James, Edgerrin
TE Wycheck, Frank
Bench Couch, Tim
Bench Heap, Todd
Bench Stewart, Kordell
Bench Portis, Clinton
Bench Gaffney, Jabar

I think it's an odd trade because I wouldn't start any of the people involved in the trade. I know all about the possibilities and the unsurety of Clinton Portis, but what do you guys know about Troy Brown and Warrick Dunn, and should I make this trade. If so, keep in mind I'd need to drop one player. Who would you drop?

First off, you have way too many quarterbacks. You should trade Fiedler and Brunell for a WR and RB and keep Portis. I'd start Stewart or Couch. Gaffney won't do much, IMO. Check your waiver wire for a replacement WR. You could safely drop Heap and get another sleeper WR or RB.