Rank Eli Manning

[Barry25]

Please rank Eli Manning as an NFL QB (Not Fantasy). Where does he fit compared to the rest of the league?

[moonhead]

middle of the pack. pretty simply mediocre.

[matmat]

Eli Manning is the third best Manning in the league.
He's also the best Eli in the NFL.

i wouldn't want to be starting him on my team every week. it'd be a QBBC

[gtabaplayr]

If I had to pick a QB to start a game for my team in the Superbowl, he would be right around 10th on my list.

EDIT: For active QBs.

[JasonSeahorn]

he's a decent quarterback, there are other much worse starters out there. he's shown flashes of great skill but also shows a lot of mistake-prone behavior, relying on lob passes to be caught by his tall wides.

[mattp987]

I think he's a clown...that's just me. He would have great success in the clowning business.

His decision making skills are very suspect...i don't know if it's just him or the Giants play calling. He took wayyyy too many sacks vs dallas, some of those we're ridiculous.

I don't think he is even going to "grow up" it seems each year is the year where Eli becomes the leader of his team....but i don't see it happening.

[eagle0588]

he's a very mediocre qb that has probably peaked. He is definitely not worthy of 1st overall pick like many other QBs. I would probably rate him around middle of all starting qbs.