knapplc wrote:josebach wrote:knapplc wrote:It's simple: If you're going to make a book into a movie, make it as exactly like the book as possible, that's all. The Harry Potter movies were very good adaptations of the books.
"Order of the Phoenix" sucked arse compared to the book.
Granted, but that's as much because it wasn't logistically possible to make that book into a movie. You get my point in general thought, right?
Sure I get your point and since LOTR is your favorite, it only makes sense you'd be extra sensitive to it.