treat24 wrote:Geoffrey Stein wrote:deerayfan072 wrote:McFadden in the second
Ok I am done
wait no I'm not. McFadden in the second
We've run a few drafts for magazines that will be released later this summer as well, and McFadden went in the second-round every one of them.
Would I take him there? No. Do I think others will? Yes.
I took AD in the 2nd round of every draft last year. Like Deeray, comparing AD and Mcfadden is ridiculous... but people will do it and 1/10 or 1/12 in your league will reach based on it...
2nd round of redrafts or keeper/dynasty? Last year I got him in the 6th round of one of my redraft leagues. I can see taking rookies early in keeper/dynasty leagues, but I'd never take one in the 1st 4-5 rounds in redraft. How many times does a rookie come in and perform like ADP in year 1? Not many. I'll take guys early that I know can perform & sometimes I'll take fliers on rookies in the middle rounds. I'll let other owners take McFadden in the 2nd this year in redraft leagues. Could he be awesome in year 1? Of course. Is it likely that we'll have an ADP type performance out of McFadden in year 1? Not IMO.