Is this team any good

[benoits bombers]

8 team league
1-qb 2-rb 3-wr 1-te 1-k 2-def
STARTERS
Qb- Kurt Warner
Rb-Corey Dillion
Rb- Garrison Hearst
Wr-David Boston
Wr-Rod Gardner
Wr-Ed McCaffrey
Te-Bubba Franks
K-Jason Elam
Def-San Fansico


BENCH
Wr-Terry Gleen
Wr-Bill Schreorder
Wr-Qadry Ismail
Wr- Kevin Dyson
Qb-David Carr
Rb- Mike Alstott

I was thinking of droping Mike Alstott for James Stewart or Clinton Portis or droping one of my bench Wr for James Stewart, Clinton Portis , Stacey Mack, or Warrick Dunn.

What's your opionon

[SolarfluX]

8 team league: 1-qb 2-rb 3-wr 1-te 1-k 2-def
STARTERS
Qb- Kurt Warner
Rb-Corey Dillion
Rb- Garrison Hearst
Wr-David Boston
Wr-Rod Gardner
Wr-Ed McCaffrey
Te-Bubba Franks
K-Jason Elam
Def-San Francisco

BENCH
Wr-Terry Glenn
Wr-Bill Schroeder
Wr-Qadry Ismail
Wr- Kevin Dyson
Qb-David Carr
Rb- Mike Alstott

I was thinking of dropping Mike Alstott for James Stewart or Clinton Portis or dropping one of my bench WRs for James Stewart, Clinton Portis, Stacey Mack or Warrick Dunn.

What's your opinion?

I would keep Alstott and drop a WR for Portis; Carr is too risky, a rookie QB on an expansion team won't hold much value. Although by week 8 (Warner's bye-week), he might be doing ok. Hearst will probably lose a lot of carries/goalline opportunities to Barlow. I wouldn't get Stewart, as he's an underachiever. Mack is only worth something if Fred Taylor gets injured and Dunn will be splitting time with T.J. Duckett (and lose goalline carries to him).

You have good depth at WR, but you need more RBs; if Dillon goes down to an injury, all your WRs won't help you. Personally, I'd start Ismail or Glenn over McCaffrey.

[Guest]

so u think i should drop a Wr for portis but if i do drop a Wr which won should i drop?.?.?

[SolarfluX]

Dyson and/or Schroeder (yes, he's a #1, but Detroit sucks).

[slowkidz]

I agree...Schroeder would be my pick to drop...He won't have as productive a year as he had in Green Bay. The QB situation in Detroit is too suspect making none of the WRs a good pick this season. Portis should have a good year behind Denver's front line, barring any more fumbles....