zoolander12 wrote:is Brandon Marshall better than Santonio Holmes?
No, not even close. Same reasoning I gave for CJ2, plus the Steelers have even more options than the Lions and probably won't be throwing enough for Holmes to out produce either of the two.
I think you mis-answered the question. You say "no" to "is Marshal better than Holmes", but your reasoning says "Yes".
I think the difference between the 3 is yardage. I think all will be close in TDs. Holmes will have substantially less catches than Marshall and a little less than CJ. But I think all will score double digit TDs this year. Holmes will score 10-12 TDs on 65 catches or so for 1,000-1,100 yards. I think Marshall could push 1,500 yards. CJ2 is the wild card to me. The guy could score a ton or just grow some more this year.
I've had a tough time deciding which 2 I should take between SSmith, Calvin, Holmes, or Marshall. I'm starting to exclude Holmes from the equation and I'm trying to decide between Smith, Calvin, and Marshall...Marshall seems like the no brainer to me with Smith and Johnson being a pick 'em because of Smith's suspension. Who would you go with?