Who should I play

[Guest]

My Qb is McNair,
But I have E James, D McAllister, S Alexander need 2
Then Rec
Owens, W Jackson, Darnell Jackson, J Mortan, M Muhammad, P Warrick
Need three. I was thinking of playing this line up

McNair
Alexander
James
Owens
Mortan
Jackson
T Gonzales
T Peterson / Pitt Def

[terpfan]

your lineup looks right to me. the only real choice u had to make was mcallister or james...

[SolarfluX]

My Qb is McNair, but I have E James, D McAllister, S Alexander (need 2)
Then WR: Owens, W Jackson, Darrell Jackson, J Morton, M Muhammad, P Warrick
(need three)
I was thinking of playing this lineup:

McNair
Alexander
James
Owens
Morton
Jackson
T Gonzalez
T Peterson / Pitt Def

[eize=7]You did not specify whether or not you are starting Willie or Darrell Jackson. My guess is that it's Darrell.
James vs. McAllister is a toss-up, since James is unproven from his injury and McAllister is just plain unproven.
I can't understand why you'd want a kicker who kicks in Heinz Field. All kickers there have a 53% accuracy rating there, which is horrible. I would drop Peterson ASAP and get yourself and nice comfy dome kicker, like Feely or Carney.

[Arlo]

Yes, there may well be a better kicker available. Otherwise, though, this team looks good. I think I'd bench James for week 1 on principle, though. McAllister should give you solid production, and I'd very much like to see James in action again before putting my faith in him. If you only had scrap heap RBs after James, you'd have to start him, but since you have McAllister, you have the luxury of being able to take a wait-and see approach.