Fantasy Football Cafe Forum

by **Ice Time X** » Wed Nov 05, 2003 10:09 pm

hey guys i need yr opinion this is the third lopsided trade in my league that has been with the same two teams

Bull Dogs are getting Chad Johnson and William Green

Pirates are getting Boston, J. Smith, and Eddie George.

the bull dogs got the great end of the deal all three times. This is there new team including the two trads before this

QB- Manning
RB- A. Green
RB- Shaun Alexander
WR- Torry Holt
WR - Chad Johnson

do u think i should tell commish to do somehtign about it

by **wholefnshow** » Wed Nov 05, 2003 10:14 pm

It sounds kind of fishy to me. I would talk to him, however he should of vetoed those trades in the first place.

by **altproject** » Wed Nov 05, 2003 10:59 pm

i don't see any problem with this trade. w. green is doo doo -- even george's stock is worth more than his right now. so, at worst, it's really smith and boston for chad johnson. there's nothing wrong with this trade. might be a tiny bit in team A's favor, but no trade is ever perfectly fair on both sides.

by **dgroundhog_ffc** » Wed Nov 05, 2003 11:00 pm

That trade seems fine to me. Willie Green got dropped in one league I'm in. With his recent 1 game suspension, and his previous struggles his value isn't that high. Chad is the best player, but Eddie George is a solid back without the questions that surround Green. I think the guy getting George wins on the RB part, and he gets a 2 for 1 at WR, both players are viable starters in almost any league.

What were the other trades? That one doesn't look anywhere NEAR lopsided. It looks like a damn fair deal to me.

I'm in a league where Vick was traded for Steve Smith early in the year. The Vick owner drafted him in the first round. Smith was a waiver claim. The Smith owner got the better of the deal, but nobody in the league thought so at the time. The trade almost killed the league people were so upset over it.