arlob wrote:The two making the deal are father and son if that helps.
If you let them in the league then you can't hold them to a different standard.
I'm not even sure which side wins that deal. Sure, Plax is the top player, but you are talking a WR1 a RB2/3 with a big downside and a TE for a QB1 (Warner is a 1 in most leagues, and at worse a high 2) a WR2 with good upside, a RB3/4 and a TE.
If I was stuck with a Kitna/Cassel type at QB I would do that deal all day long.