karabell is far better than berry at football. Berry is the god of basketball though.
i still remember when karabell made the call to not only pick up willie parker, but to start him week 1 of his rookie year. he's been money so many times.
berry seems more knowledgeable from the way he writes, but then the week goes by and you look back and realize almost all his calls were wrong (or barely right). He'll give himself a "good call" if some RB he chose scored more than 12 fantasy points... Berry has guts, but that doesn't make him accurate. He is all stats, no substance. Not once have I heard Berry mention watching a game and basing a projection off of how a player looks on the field, which is one of hte most important factors.