Some have asked for a veto, should I?

[kmullen73]

I've got a message from a couple people about vetoing this trade in the league. Commish veto only.

MBIII
Marvin
DeAngelo Williams

for

Chris Johnson
Reggie Wayne
Buckhalter

I'm think no right now, but it's a little lopsided I think.

[padrino990_200]

i dont see that as being lopsided, and even if it was thats no reason to veto it. unless you think there is collusion going on you have to let it through, as each owner may have their own sound reasoning for making the trade

[WaCougMBS]

i dont see that as being lopsided, and even if it was thats no reason to veto it. unless you think there is collusion going on you have to let it through, as each owner may have their own sound reasoning for making the trade

There is nothing even potentially collusive about this trade IMO - it is absolutely unvetoable...

MBIII is more valuable than CJ4.24, Wayne is obviously more valuable than Marvin at this point, and the backup RBs are a wash (maybe with a slight advantage to DeAngelo, but he is still very hit and miss - both are nothing more than flex plays IMO). This is a pretty darned even trade in all formats, and I don't think a difference in taste is reason for a veto.

Hope this help

[Script-Ohio]

HELL NO you can't veto that.

[kmullen73]

#2 People are complaining to me about this one also

Orton
Campbell
T. Jones
S. Smith(car)
Dunn

for

Flacco
Ferrotte
Breaston
Graham
Grant.

I think this one is a little more lopsided, but I don't think it a veto either. Thoughts? Thanks for the replies.

[padrino990_200]

tell people in your league to worry about their own teams and stop trying to veto every trade. those are both fair deals. i dont see how either are lopsided in any way

[WaCougMBS]

#2 People are complaining to me about this one also

Orton
Campbell
T. Jones
S. Smith(car)
Dunn

for

Flacco
Ferrotte
Breaston
Graham
Grant.

I think this one is a little more lopsided, but I don't think it a veto either. Thoughts? Thanks for the replies.

No chance on this one either. Its not totally even on paper, but nowhere near a veto. We talked about your post on the Locker Room Logic podcast

[kmullen73]

Thanks for discussing it on the show, I sent the link to my league-mates. Hopefully it helps.