Keeper Question

[joshiasi]

I know its a long way before the new season starts... but i was just wondering... in our league we keep 8 players and from my lineup... which 8 players would you keep? Its a 14 Team Yahoo H2H league.

QB - Tom Brady
WR - Plaxico Buress
WR - Greg Jennings
RB - Joseph Addai
RB - DeAngelo Williams
TE - Antonio Gates
W/R - Kevin Faulk
K - Josh Brown
DEF - New Orleans
D - James Harrison
DB - Will Blackmon
DL - Justin Tuck

B - Patrick Crayton
B - Matt Cassel
B - Julius Jones
B - Heath Miller
B - Ryan Torrain
B - Devin Hester

Thanks in advance

[bungle613]

Your scoring and starting req's will play apart in the choice, can you post those?

Brady
Jennings
Addai
DWill
Gates
J. Jones

Those are the starting 6 for me and then it comes down to Harrison, Tuck, Torain, Cassel and maybe even Plax but Plax would not be on my list if I had to declare now. Maybe in 6 months when things play out he would be there but right now, he is undraftable until very late in a draft.

[joshiasi]

here is the scoring system of the league:

Passing Yards 25 yards per point
Passing Touchdowns 6
Interceptions -1
Sacks -1
Rushing Yards 10 yards per point
Rushing Touchdowns 6
Reception Yards 10 yards per point
Reception Touchdowns 6
Return Touchdowns 6
2-Point Conversions 2
Fumbles Lost -2
Off Fumble Return TD 6
Field Goals 0-19 Yards 3
Field Goals 20-29 Yards 3
Field Goals 30-39 Yards 4
Field Goals 40-49 Yards 5
Field Goals 50+ Yards 6
Pt After Attempt Made 1
Pt After Attempt Missed -1
Sack 1
Interception 1
Touchdown 6
Safety 2
Kickoff and Punt Ret TD 6
Points Allowed 0 points 10
Points Allowed 1-6 pts 7
Points Allowed 7-13 pts 4
Points Allowed 14-20 pts 1
Points Allowed 21-27 pts 0
Points Allowed 28-34 pts -1
Points Allowed 35+ pts -4
Tackle Solo 1
Sack 1
Interception 1
Fumble Force 1
Fumble Recovery 1
Touchdown 6
Safety 2
Block Kick 1

[bungle613]

Well, your IDP scoring makes it tough to keep anyone. Too bad since oyu ahve the #1 LB and #1 DL in the roster. IDP is just so tough to evaluate as well, it is rare that players have back to back solid years.

I would keep Torain as my 7th choice as of right now and it is a pure coin flip for the last spot. I think it will likely be Cassel by the time you ahve to declare as I am skeptical that Brady will be ready for opening day. Really, just oo many questions surrounding your 8th keeper to answer.

[Indibuck]

I know its a long way before the new season starts... but i was just wondering... in our league we keep 8 players and from my lineup... which 8 players would you keep? Its a 14 Team Yahoo H2H league.

QB - Tom Brady
WR - Plaxico Buress
WR - Greg Jennings
RB - Joseph Addai
RB - DeAngelo Williams
TE - Antonio Gates
W/R - Kevin Faulk
K - Josh Brown
DEF - New Orleans
D - James Harrison
DB - Will Blackmon
DL - Justin Tuck

B - Patrick Crayton
B - Matt Cassel
B - Julius Jones
B - Heath Miller
B - Ryan Torrain
B - Devin Hester

Thanks in advance

Brady
Cassell
Addai
Jennings
Williams
Gates
Torain
J. Jones

[MadDog36]

QB - Tom Brady
WR - Greg Jennings
RB - Joseph Addai
RB - DeAngelo Williams
RB - Ryan Torrain
TE - Antonio Gates

Last spot toss up between cassel and jones. I think Julius is garbage and only worth rostering in the deepest of leagues. Yuck. If Cassel goes somewhere else I think he's worth the risk of your 8th keeper. Besides you'll have two great QBs if he goes somewhere else and the best handcuff in the game if not. Trade bait...

[BigBadBrawler]

I'd keep:
DWill
Addai
Jennings
Brady
Gates
Plax
Harrison
Torain/JJ (I'm not sold on Torain at all, so this is close for me)

[TruNinerFan]

Brady
D Will
Addai
Jennings
Plax
Gates
Torain
Harrison

Keep a close eye on Torain. He could very well be the starter in a high power Denver offense next year. Remember, there is no more Shanahan messing with fantasy owners.