I've been going back and forth with one of the owners in my dynasty league who insists that his team is better than mine. I'd like you guys to tell me which team you think is better. Thank you
Team A: QB (start 1): McNabb, J. Russell RB (start 2): Lynch, D. Ward, McFadden, E. Graham WR (start 2): Boldin, Colsten, Ginn Jr., Burress, J. Nelson TE (start 1): Gates, Cooley DL (start 2): D. Ware, J. Tuck LB (start 2): Hawk, McIntosh, B. James, Witherspoon DB (start 2): C. Woodson, T. Davis, Merriweather, R. Harper K (start 1): M Bryant RB/WR (start 1) WR/TE (start 1) DP (start 2)
Team B: QB (start 1): Campbell, Warner, Leinart RB: (start 2): M. Barber, Portis, White, Betts, C. Smith WR (Start 2); A. Johnson, E. Royal, Muhsin Muhammed, Curtis TE (start 1): Witten DL (Start 2): Suggs, Freeny, C. Pace LB (start 2): Dansby, Tatupu, Vilma, S. Cooper DB (start 2): Antoine Bethea, Bob Sanders, M. Brown RB/WR (start 1) WR/TE (start 1) K (start 1 ): Gostkowski DP (start 2)
madaslives911 wrote:What's your league scoring system?
Yeah . . . that would help, wouldn't it? lol.
Here ya go:
Passing TD Pass 6 Every 50 passing yards 1 300-399 yard passing game 3 400+ yard passing game 3 2pt Passing Conversion 2 Interceptions Thrown -2.5 Every Time Sacked -2
Rushing TD Rush 6 2pt Rushing Conversion 2 Every 20 rushing yards 1 100-199 yard rushing game 3 200+ yard rushing game 6
Receiving TD Reception 6 2pt Receiving Conversion 2 Every 20 receiving yards 1 Each reception 0.5 100-199 yard receiving game 3 200+ yard receiving game 6
Miscellaneous Fumble Recovered for TD 6 Each Fumble Lost -2.5 Kickoff Return TD 6 Punt Return TD 6 Every 25 kickoff return yards 1 Every 25 punt return yards 1
Kicking FG Made (50+ yards) 4 FG Made (40-49 yards) 3.5 FG Made (0-39 yards) 3 FG Missed (0-39 yards) -0.3 Each PAT Made 1 Each PAT Missed -1
Defensive Players Blocked Punt or FG return for TD 6 Each Interception 2.5 Each Fumble Recovered 1 Blocked Punt, PAT or FG 3 Each Safety 4.5 Each Sack 1.5 Interception Return TD 6 Fumble Return TD 6 Each Fumble Forced 1.5 Every Assisted Tackle 0.5 Every Solo Tackle 1 Passes Defensed 1.5
strider2k2 wrote:I've been going back and forth with one of the owners in my dynasty league who insists that his team is better than mine. I'd like you guys to tell me which team you think is better. Thank you
Team A: QB (start 1): McNabb, J. Russell RB (start 2): Lynch, D. Ward, McFadden, E. Graham WR (start 2): Boldin, Colsten, Ginn Jr., Burress, J. Nelson TE (start 1): Gates, Cooley DL (start 2): D. Ware, J. Tuck LB (start 2): Hawk, McIntosh, B. James, Witherspoon DB (start 2): C. Woodson, T. Davis, Merriweather, R. Harper K (start 1): M Bryant RB/WR (start 1) WR/TE (start 1) DP (start 2)
Team B: QB (start 1): Campbell, Warner, Leinart RB: (start 2): M. Barber, Portis, White, Betts, C. Smith WR (Start 2); A. Johnson, E. Royal, Muhsin Muhammed, Curtis TE (start 1): Witten DL (Start 2): Suggs, Freeny, C. Pace LB (start 2): Dansby, Tatupu, Vilma, S. Cooper DB (start 2): Antoine Bethea, Bob Sanders, M. Brown RB/WR (start 1) WR/TE (start 1) K (start 1 ): Gostkowski DP (start 2)
Thanks in advance for the help.
here are my thoughts...
QB - i think both teams are just about even here with respect to their main QB starter but Team B could have a good edge if Warner decides to still play with the Airzone; even if he lands somewhere else, for as long as he had good weapons to throw to, he will be a a major force in the passing attack.
RBs - team A has good depth in the RB position and the players he got have the potential to explode. On the other hand, Team B have 2 proven RBs who can be considered TD machines. If both RBs manage to stay healthy, they could come up with nice fantasy stats in your PPR league. Lendale White would be a fine play in bye-weeks or a decent replacement should Barber and Portis goes down on an injury.
WRs - at this point in time, Boldin and Burress' future are still questionable. But having good depth again, Team A should have no worries fielding in Colston and Ginn as his starters. Nelson has a nice sleeper value too. Going over to Team B, he has a solid WR in the person of Andre Johnson. Royal could emerge as an elite WR considering his great games in the 2008 season. The backup WRs could be a little iffy but nevertheless, Team B could have a very slight edge in the WR department.
TEs - Team A definitely has a strong edge here as he has two of the quality TEs. Team B should be able to get a decent back-up TE else this spot could spell some trouble in case where Witten gets sidelined by an injury.
IDPs - D. Ware and Justin Tuck are solid points maker but overall, Team B's IDPs seem stronger... i'd give the edge to Team B.
K - might not be considered as a factor to others but the Pats' high-scoring offense could provide additional scoring opportunity for Team B.
Overall and considering that this is an IDP + a PPR league, i think Team B has a better team.
Hi there. I'm team A. The lineup above is not entirely correct due to some recent trades. Here is my current lineup:
QB- Mcnabb, Cassell RB- Lynch, Mcfadden, Ward WR- Colsten, Owens, Gin Jr., Boldin, Jordy Nelson TE- Gates, Cooley DL- Tuck, Ware LB- A.J. Hawk, Rocky Mcintosh, Will Witherspoon, Nick Barnett, Bradie James DB- Charles Woodson, Thomas Davis, Brandon Meriweather, Roman Harper K- Matt Bryant
It is also important to note that I am in negotiations to add either a top 10 DL or LB.
Take this roster and rate it versus team B's and tell me your opinion. Thanks.
fab401 wrote:Hi there. I'm team A. The lineup above is not entirely correct due to some recent trades. Here is my current lineup:
QB- Mcnabb, Cassell RB- Lynch, Mcfadden, Ward WR- Colsten, Owens, Gin Jr., Boldin, Jordy Nelson TE- Gates, Cooley DL- Tuck, Ware LB- A.J. Hawk, Rocky Mcintosh, Will Witherspoon, Nick Barnett, Bradie James DB- Charles Woodson, Thomas Davis, Brandon Meriweather, Roman Harper K- Matt Bryant
It is also important to note that I am in negotiations to add either a top 10 DL or LB.
Take this roster and rate it versus team B's and tell me your opinion. Thanks.
Hmmm... the addition of Cassell and Owens and the transfer of Ward to the Bucs carry some significant impact on Team A's roster. Lemme know the latest trade developments and then i will re-assess the teams.
QB- McNabb, Hasselbeck RB- Lynch, Frank Gore, Ronnie Brown, McFadden WR- Boldin, TO, Colsten, Gin JR., Jordy Nelson TE- Gates, Cooley DL- Tuck, Ware LB- AJ Hawk, Nick Barnett, Bradie James, Rocky Mcintosh, Will Witherspoon DB- Roman Harper, Charles Woodson, Brandon Merriweather, Thomas Davis K- Matt Bryant
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by strider2k2 » Tue Feb 24, 2009 5:04 pm 
.
