His Marion Barber, Tashard Choice, Green Bay Defense, 4.08 for my Jonathan Stewart, Pittsburgh Defense, 2.06, and 3.10. I would be left with 1.01, 2.11, 4.05, 4.06, 4.08. PPR League. I'm really high in on Marion Barber and his Receptions draw me to him.
My Team
Rodgers, Aaron Addai, Joseph Brown, Ronnie McGahee, Willis Stewart, Jonathan Wayne, Reggie Williams, Roy Harrison, Marvin Kelly, Malcolm Thomas, Devin Keller, Dustin Gould, Robbie Steelers, Pittsburgh
His Team
Cassel, Matt Rivers, Philip Barber, Marion Choice, Tashard Jones-Drew, Maurice Mendenhall, Rashard Parker, Willie Avery, Donnie Douglas, Harry Holt, Torry JAC Jones, Matt Marshall, Brandon Walter, Kevin Celek, Brent Cooley, Chris Kaeding, Nate Packers, Green Bay
I probably wouldnt do it, but then again I dont like Barber at all. In a dynasty I definitely like Stewart better, combine that with you giving up 2 higher draft picks than you are receiving and also giving up a better defense I would say no.
Not a bad deal at all, I would roll with it but depends how high you are on each guy...Personally I love Stewart and feel like he can be a top 10 back at some point, but it may not be for another few years when/if DWill leaves...Everyone is brushing him aside but Fox is going to let DWill be the starter while he's in Carolina bar none.
So knowing that, Barber is ahead of Stewart in the short term, and getting Choice is a nice throw in, because when Barber starts to decline or lose carries you have the handcuff(and Choice is damn good, better then just an average handcuff and will have incredible value once he starts getting 15 carries consistently), and you also have the option of moving Barber after awhile for a top tier RB(if you can get one) so you'd have two solid backs instead of one...I'd take it, makes your line-up stronger right now, and your still set up nicely for the future, Barber isn't really old either.
Who are you planning to take with your 1.01? Looks like Crabtree would be a perfect addition to your line-up.
Current Cafe Dynasties: 4th and Goal Fourth & Inches Double D Any Given Dynasty Eat Cheese Dynasty NFL's Finest Cafe Very Special Forces
LS2throwed wrote:Not a bad deal at all, I would roll with it but depends how high you are on each guy...Personally I love Stewart and feel like he can be a top 10 back at some point, but it may not be for another few years when/if DWill leaves...Everyone is brushing him aside but Fox is going to let DWill be the starter while he's in Carolina bar none.
So knowing that, Barber is ahead of Stewart in the short term, and getting Choice is a nice throw in, because when Barber starts to decline or lose carries you have the handcuff(and Choice is damn good, better then just an average handcuff and will have incredible value once he starts getting 15 carries consistently), and you also have the option of moving Barber after awhile for a top tier RB(if you can get one) so you'd have two solid backs instead of one...I'd take it, makes your line-up stronger right now, and your still set up nicely for the future, Barber isn't really old either.
Who are you planning to take with your 1.01? Looks like Crabtree would be a perfect addition to your line-up.
Well I actually counter-offered a little bit better of a trade for me.
Stewart, Jonathan PIT Def 2.11 3.10 4.05
For
Barber, Marion Choice, Tashard Packers, Green Bay 2.01 4.08
As for the 1.01 I'm still probably going to go with Moreno even though I'm weak at WR. I want to stack up at RB and then just take WRS later in the draft. Plus I'm not real sure if Crabtree has been going 1.01 at all or not. A little help on this would be great.
I like your counter to his trade a little bit better.
I love Stewart and think he can be a top-10 if not top-5 RB at some point... but barring injury to DWill it will be a while until he gets the opportunity.
As for your 1.1 pick.... I think you have to take a RB there, or if you want Crabtree, trade down to 1.3 and get an extra pick thrown in. Conventional wisdom says to take Moreno, but I like Wells better, both for this year and following years.
I think that you are giving up too much in this trade and it doesn't make sense to trade away a quality young rb, a top def and draft picks for a big downgrade a def, less picks and rb who is probably about equal. I think that J.Stew will have a much more productive second season, he will be healthy and they are a run first team. I would stick with what you have for now. Good luck.
dblj9911 wrote:I think that you are giving up too much in this trade and it doesn't make sense to trade away a quality young rb, a top def and draft picks for a big downgrade a def, less picks and rb who is probably about equal. I think that J.Stew will have a much more productive second season, he will be healthy and they are a run first team. I would stick with what you have for now. Good luck.
Well I think Stewart will not be as good because he has to beat out DWilliams and Barber will be on a better team this year. Plus PPR should push him over the top. Plus GB's defense will be top 10 this year. And I get Choice whos a good handcuff also.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by packers140 » Sun May 10, 2009 11:41 pm 
