Who is better

[jayne_cobb]

Scoring system

RB TD=6, yards 1pt for 10 yrds rush/receive. 1 point per reception
Defensive players
6 pts per sack. 6pts per int ,2 pts per forced fumbl,e 1 point per tackle, 6points per sack

James Davis
Andre Brown
Or
Brian Orakpo

[bungle613]

Orakpo is the best player listed by far.. problem is he is an IDP which are easily replaced. Your IDP scoring is large so I see the temptation.

I would take Andre Brown personally.

[thriftyrocker]

6 pts per sack = wow
Orakpo has an amazing opportunity lining up next to Haynesworth.

vs. a RB who might start off 4th on the depth chart

With this scoring, if Orakpo starts off well I think you can trade him for a RB much better than Andre Brown.

Hard to say for sure without knowing how many teams and your current roster.

[haloswin2002]

6 pts per sack = wow
Orakpo has an amazing opportunity lining up next to Haynesworth.

vs. a RB who might start off 4th on the depth chart

With this scoring, if Orakpo starts off well I think you can trade him for a RB much better than Andre Brown.

Hard to say for sure without knowing how many teams and your current roster.

Yeah, no kidding. With this scoring you are looking for the next Ware/Merriman almost as much as the next Forte/C. Johnson.