PPR question - Bush or Chris Johnson?

[dmacblue]

Id always prefer a Bush over a Johnson

(especially as your getting to retain Edwards)

[nateb]

I would do the deal. Braylon isn't going to start for you and you're upgrading to a potential top 3 RB.

[Asskickas]

I would do the deal. Braylon isn't going to start for you and you're upgrading to a potential top 3 RB.

I have to change my tune on this 1 after doing a little research. Braylon is the key. Can he bounce back to his 07' stats? After checking his schedule I have to think the answer is NO! He has a green QB and a pretty tough schedule. CJ on the other hand will continue to be featured since the Titan's passing game is what it is...mediocre at best. Bush even though he gets receptions won't off set the yardage and tds you're likely to get from CJ while Braylon is likely to be fixed to your bench after putting up sorry #s in week 1-3 Vikings, Broncos, and Ravens.

Having Chris Johnson, Sjax, Addai and Gore is pretty sweet when you also have Steve Smith, Roddy, Fitz and Calvin. You should go unbeaten all season!!

Yeah I'd do the deal after second thought.

[LS2throwed]

I would do the deal. Braylon isn't going to start for you and you're upgrading to a potential top 3 RB.

I have to change my tune on this 1 after doing a little research. Braylon is the key. Can he bounce back to his 07' stats? After checking his schedule I have to think the answer is NO! He has a green QB and a pretty tough schedule. CJ on the other hand will continue to be featured since the Titan's passing game is what it is...mediocre at best. Bush even though he gets receptions won't off set the yardage and tds you're likely to get from CJ while Braylon is likely to be fixed to your bench after putting up sorry #s in week 1-3 Vikings, Broncos, and Ravens.

Having Chris Johnson, Sjax, Addai and Gore is pretty sweet when you also have Steve Smith, Roddy, Fitz and Calvin. You should go unbeaten all season!!

Yeah I'd do the deal after second thought.

That's my thinking, even if Braylon bounces back I don't see him cracking the line-up past his 4 WR's he already has, and CJ has the potential to be one of his best RB's only going into his 2nd year...Braylon has QB issues and he's going to get doubled and tripled until they get another threat, and Bush is coming off of Microfracture.


Your basically giving up your worst RB and worst WR out of the major group, so those are the guys to trade if you do at all...It'll be hard for any WR you draft to pass Roddy, Fitz, and Calvin each week regardless, it's worth getting a RB upgrade and I think CJ can post 2000 yards eventually.