Proposed Trade.........Pierre?

[lylefish]

Any takes on this proposed trade?
Brown, Ronnie MIA RB
Williams, Ricky MIA RB
Rivers, Philip SDC QB
Berrian, Bernard MIN WR
For
Palmer, Carson CIN QB (P)
Thomas, Pierre NOS RB
Jennings, Greg GBP WR

I need another top starting wr in Jennings but is pierre going to be the stud in NO?




Pretty standard ppr keeper league
roster:
Philip Rivers
Aaron Rodgers
Tyler Thigpen
Ronnie Brown
Steven Jackson
Clinton Portis
Ricky Williams
Bernard Berrian
Laveranues Coles
Lee Evans
Calvin Johnson
Sidney Rice
Eddie Royal
Chris Cooley
Jay Feely
Carolina Panthers

[TruNinerFan]

I would take this trade. You are getting a major upgrade at WR and I actually don't think you are downgrading that much from Ronnie Brown to Pierre Thomas. He is gaining the advantage in the QB swap, but Rodgers is your starter anyways. I think this is a good trade for you.

[grover99]

I would take this trade. You are getting a major upgrade at WR and I actually don't think you are downgrading that much from Ronnie Brown to Pierre Thomas. He is gaining the advantage in the QB swap, but Rodgers is your starter anyways. I think this is a good trade for you.

Exactly what I was going to say.

[lylefish]

Well, the trade is in and he wants to sub out Jennings for Santonio Holmes which I refused. I countered by offering my third round pick 5 in addition to the other offer for Jennings. I have 3 other picks in the third round. Waiting on his response.
Thanks for the comments.

[Tejones8]

Well, the trade is in and he wants to sub out Jennings for Santonio Holmes which I refused. I countered by offering my third round pick 5 in addition to the other offer for Jennings. I have 3 other picks in the third round. Waiting on his response.
Thanks for the comments.

Even if you have to give up the 3rd rounder, this trades a must for you. A core of Aaron Rodgers, Calvin Johnson, Greg Jennings, SJax, and Portis is about as good as it gets.