Biggest KEEPER deal yet

[Mathew11.]

Its in a 12 team KEEPER league. Yes or No or maybe a re counter

I Give:Gore ( RB of 49ers), Jennings ( WR of GB) and Crabtree ( WR of 49ers)
I Get:Chris Johnson ( RB of TEN), Gonzalez ( WR of Indy) and Burleson ( WR of Seattle)

MY TEAM:
QB:Tom Brady
WR:Greg Jennings, Eddie Royal
RB:Frank Gore, Kevin Smith
TE: Tony Gonzalez
W/R/T: Willie Parker
BN:Hines Ward, Willie, Derrick Mason, Heath Miller and Jason Campbell and Nate Burleson
K: David Akers
DEF: Minnesota

His Team:
QB: Peyton Manning
WR: Roy Williams, Anthony Gonzalez
RB: Chris Johnson, LenDale White
TE: Jeremy Schockey
W/R/T: Michael Crabtree
BN: Marshawn Lynch, Brandon Pettigrew , Jerious Norwood, Brady Quinn and Ramses Barden
K: Nick Folk
DEF: New England


Maybe i can do a re counter and with the re counter i hop that every1 that is reading this can help me give him a new offer.


TY!!

[Mathew11.]

Plz help me guyz

[brrett]

I wouldnt do this.SF is going to focus the offense on Gore this year, so he could have a better year than Johnson who wil still lose touches to White.Jennings is better than Gonzalez.

[Mathew11.]

OK then plz tell me a re counter that i should make to send to him.

[Tejones8]

I wouldn't even consider. While Johnson is ranked higher then Gore by most, I feel they're pretty close. Meanwhile, Jennings is head and shoulders better then Gonzo, and I'd rather have Crabtree then Burleson.

[Mathew11.]

OK but lets say Gore would not run a lot ( TEAM WOULD FOCUS ON PASS) ( NOT A CHANCE BUT LETS JUST SAY) and i would wanna trade him what would i offer to this guy i just wanna SE what u come up with

[mattb47]

This is a terrible deal for you...the only part that you arguably win on is getting Chris Johnson but to be honest, I don't think it's really a monster upgrade for you and certainly not enough to warrant TWO downgrades at WR. Greg Jennings is a guy with top 5 potential and Crabtree has some special talent that you don't want to give away this cheaply.

Why are you trying to trade Gore now? This is the classic "don't sell low" idea...his value isn't crazy high right now so trading him now makes no sense...I think he's going to have a significantly better year than he had last year so I'd wait if you're trying to unload him. This is just so far not in your favor (and most deals involving him probably will be similar) so I'd hold onto what you have for now.

[Hank_Scorpio]

No way should you do this deal.

I Give:Gore ( RB of 49ers), Jennings ( WR of GB) and Crabtree ( WR of 49ers)
I Get:Chris Johnson ( RB of TEN), Gonzalez ( WR of Indy) and Burleson ( WR of Seattle)

Jennings has proven he's a #1 WR; A Gonzalez has not. You give up Crabtree, whose potential is sky-high, and you get Burleson, a guy who can't stay healthy and has had one good season out of five.

So, overall, you are perhaps even at RB, but you give up the better WR prospect with Crabtree over A Gonzalez, and you give up a definate keeper WR in Jennings and get a WR3 in Burleson.

I think you had better turn that one down.

I'd like to help you with a counter-offer, but your roster comments are confusing. It says you are giving up Crabtree in the deal and getting Burleson. But your roster has Burleson and his roster already has Crabtree. Please clarify the roster situation and I'llmake a suggestion or two...

[thriftyrocker]

If the deal is actually

Gore + Jennings + Burleson

for

CJ + Gonzalez + Crabtree

I would actually do this deal.

CJ is a lot more valuable than Gore in a keeper league.

Jennings is worth more than Crabtree, but Crabtree's ceiling is just as high.

Gonzalez is lot better than Burleson.

If you're getting Crabtree, this seems a very good way to make your team younger and increase overall potential.

[Mathew11.]

Ya i made a mistake i get Crabtree and i give away Burleson. Sorry