Dynasty Wayne or Crabtree and Ginn?

[larryalcohol33]

It is a PPR and I have a good shot at winning it this year, we start 1 qb 2-3 RB 2-3 WR 1TE 1D 1K. RB's and WR's are 1pt for 10 yards and 1 ppr.

HEre is my roster. WOuld you accept the offer?


Brady, Tom NEP QB (P) - 8 FA
Bulger, Marc STL QB - 9 FA
Russell, JaMarcus OAK QB - 9 FA
White, Pat MIA QB (R) - 6 4.06
Bush, Michael OAK RB - 9 FA
Bush, Reggie NOS RB (P) - 5 FA
Choice, Tashard DAL RB - 6 FA
Jones-Drew, Maurice JAC RB - 7 FA
McFadden, Darren OAK RB (P) - 9 FA
Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB - 8 FA
Williams, Carnell TBB RB (Q) - 8 FA
Williams, Ricky MIA RB - 6 FA
Baskett, Hank PHI WR - 4 FA
Crabtree, Michael SFO WR (R) - 6 1.01
Curtis, Kevin PHI WR (P) - 4 FA
Doucet, Early ARI WR - 4 FA
Ginn Jr., Ted MIA WR - 6 FA
Harvin, Percy MIN WR (R) - 9 1.12
Henry, Chris CIN WR - 8 FA
Kelly, Malcolm WAS WR (P) - 8 FA
Marshall, Brandon DEN WR (P) - 7 FA
Moss, Randy NEP WR - 8 FA
Stallworth, Donte' CLE WR - 9 FA
Clark, Dallas IND TE - 6 FA
Davis, Vernon SFO TE - 6 FA
McMichael, Randy STL TE (Q) - 9 FA
Longwell, Ryan MIN PK - 9 FA
Chargers, San Diego SDC Def - 5 FA
Dolphins, Miami MIA Def - 6 FA
Redskins, Washington WAS Def - 8 5.06

[GiantsFanNJ]

Pulling the trigger on this trade will increase ur chance of winning this year...
However...I would stand pat...U will still be in contention...
Wayne is over 30....and although u dont have a clearcut WR3 ...one or more will emerge out that group of top young WR's sooner than later...and be around for the next 10 years...

[dblj9911]

Well I think that with Moss and Marshall you have two top wr right now and one of your other wr will step up and give you a quality #3wr. I can see Henry having a good year this year and should provide you some quality games also. I think you are fine and should keep your young players for the future.
I really do like Wayne, I think he has another 2-3 years of top production but I think that Crabtree is going to be starting in SF and posting quality numbers by next season. Good luck.

[larryalcohol33]

It comes down to starting mcfadden/other WR or Wayne. I think wayne would be a great addition this year but I am concerned about giving up the future by trading crabtree and ginn.

[Tejones8]

I may be in the minoirty, but when I've got a chance to win in a dynasty league, I go for it. I'd rather worry about winning now then winning in the future. I say go for it!

[bmor8811]

It comes down to starting mcfadden/other WR or Wayne. I think wayne would be a great addition this year but I am concerned about giving up the future by trading crabtree and ginn.

I think DMac or someone of those young WRs, maybe even Crabtree if their QB situation gets better, can step up and be a steady Flex guy.

Crabtree WILL be a stud sooner rather than later, and the thing is you can still win without him. Wayne, while I like him for maybe 1-2 more years but then both him and Manning will be slowly getting older and less effective. Ginn isn't a bad spot-start either at least for the immediate future.