A Rodger+LT for J Cambell+MJD (WHIR)

[ninremix]

I have been offered MJD and Jason Cambell for Aaron Rodgers and LT.

I think I am giving up too much plus I am weak at QB with Eli as my backup so I am leaning toward rejecting the offer, BUT I might be able to land Schuab as my backup QB ... if so should I take the deal?


--------------------
12 Team, 20 player Keeper, Dynasty league (PPR)

These are my potential 20 keepers...
QB: A Rodgers-E Manning
RB: L Tomlinson-M Turner-R Brown
WR: T Ownes-M Colston-H Ward-K Walter
TE: T Gonzalez-J Shockey
DL: T Suggs-O Umenyiora-D Docket
LB: A Pierce-D Harris-B Urlacher-C Lofton
DB: A Wilson-C Bailey-C Gamble

Practice Squad: (all transfer over to 2009)
Jurious Norwood
Daren Sproles
John David Booty
Devon Bess
Devin Thomas
Jacob Hester

1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 2FLEX, 1K, 2DL, 2LB, 2DB, 1ST
Off PPR: 1pt recpt, 1pt 10yd rush/recp, 1pt 25 pass, (+pts for big plays)
Def: 2pt tkl (.5 ast), 2pt FF/FR/Int, 4pt Sack, 6 pt TD

[Kareighuis]

Wow- the chance to have MJD and Burner side-by-side in a dynasty...

Losing out on Rodgers would be tough, but I'd reluctantly do it. If you can get Schaub, I'd do it quickly.

[dblj9911]

Well you have a big drop off in qb with losing out on Rodgers and that would really hurt your team. I do think that LT is going to rebound this year and have a quality season, but MJD has youth on his side and two new young tackles, which should help him out for the next few years. I don't think I would make this move unless I had something worked out for another qb. Good luck.

[TruNinerFan]

If you are sure you can land Schaub, then I would make the trade.

[Egg2828]

MJD and Turner are worth the set back at QB. That is HUGE and will be for years to come. Gotta get another QB though!

[djadrock]

IF you can get Shaub do it. Honestly, if you can't get Shaub still do it. You lose one good year of LT, a good Rodgers career and you get a stud MJD!! Campbell is just trash to even out numbers.

Help viewtopic.php?f=18&t=438392

[hammertoes]

I say go for it. It sucks losing Rodgers, but you have to give to get, and I'd take MJD over Rodgers every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

There will be a surprise QB that you can pick up a couple weeks into the season, even if you can't get Schaub.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=438280