Indibuck wrote:10-team, H2H keeper league. Standard scoring with bonuses for long TDs. No PPR.
Start 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 1D
Which team do you like better?
Team A QB McNabb RB AP RB Ronnie Brown RB Ryan Grant WR Colston WR Braylon Edwards TE Tony Gonzalez
Team B QB Brady RB Ronnie Brown RB Ryan Grant RB Beanie Wells WR Randy Moss WR Colston WR Edwards
As always, leave a link and I will help in return. Thanks for your advice.
I've gone back and forth on this one and I'm going to go with Team A.
I think Peterson potential for huge games gives this team a slight advantage. I think with Brady coming off an injury he will be slow to produce huge numbers, leaving the gap between him and McNabb slim. I feel like Gonzalez will put up his usual great numbers but on a much better team, giving him more TD opportunities. Giving him the edge over aging Moss and his occasional big play.
Indi man, I have come to answer this ne for you twice already and can't pick a side. IT is really freakin close.
Team A Team B QB McNabb << QB Brady RB AP >>>>> RB Beanie Wells RB Ronnie Brown = RB Ronnie Brown RB Ryan Grant = RB Ryan Grant WR Colston = WR Colston WR Braylon Edwards = WR Edwards TE Tony Gonzalez <<<< WR Randy Moss
Moss smokes Gonzo, AD smokes Wells. Brady I believe will handily outpoint McNabb but all in all, the points will be close. With having to start 3 Wr's... I would give the nod to team B. I would also likely pass on drafting Wells as my RB3.
Moss/Brady won't be setting anymore records and I think Brady might stay healthy but wouldn't be surprised if he has some nagging pains that slow him down a bit. AP vs Wells is no contest and makes up for the 2-4pts/week lost for losing Brady and the 1-3 lost for losing Moss. It's close but I just don't think they can do it again so soon after a season ending injury. $0.02
I thought it might be close, but it seems like everyone is pretty well split.
I have AP right now, and obviously is the key component for a trade involving Brady/Moss/Wells. I hate to trade away the best player in a non-PPR league, but... what's the saying about buying low, and selling high? AP is never ever going to have higher value. The $64,000 question is how long to ride the stud RB before his value takes a hit... I have no reason to believe that AP will have any less value over the next 3 years, but you never know with any of these players...
I think I will probably decline this deal and see if I can get a better offer... I'm not in a hurry!
If someone else can give me a reason to not wait and to go ahead and pull the trigger on this deal, I would love to have you try and sell me on it.
I thought it might be close, but it seems like everyone is pretty well split.
I have AP right now, and obviously is the key component for a trade involving Brady/Moss/Wells. I hate to trade away the best player in a non-PPR league, but... what's the saying about buying low, and selling high? AP is never ever going to have higher value. The $64,000 question is how long to ride the stud RB before his value takes a hit... I have no reason to believe that AP will have any less value over the next 3 years, but you never know with any of these players...
I think I will probably decline this deal and see if I can get a better offer... I'm not in a hurry!
If someone else can give me a reason to not wait and to go ahead and pull the trigger on this deal, I would love to have you try and sell me on it.
I like bungle's logic...and he might be right. I like team A better. I'd keep ADP til the wheels fall off or I got an offer that just blew me away. And I'd want a proven RB in return. I wouldn't want to rely on Wells as your 3rd RB. He might be great. He might be a bust. We just don't know. How many years does Moss have left? He's 32 now. I don't think the upgrade at QB & WR is worth it. Good luck!
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by 
