J. Stewart for D. McFadden?

[LegendoftheFall]

i disagree with earlier posters. I dont think Stewart will ever overtake Deangelo as the #1 and will always be stuck in a timeshare, Deangelo Williams is not a 1 year wonder like many people think. He was a beast in college and a beast in his first real chance to play in the NFL- a poor man's LT. but i think its just a matter of time before McFadden takes over the Oakland job for good. McFadden is a special talent and showed it the only game he was healthy last year. In a redraft league, id probably still take Stewart, but in a dynasty i like Mcfadden. Only the immediate payoff and extra draft pick would sway me to trade for Stewart.

[aaawall91]

i disagree with earlier posters. I dont think Stewart will ever overtake Deangelo as the #1 and will always be stuck in a timeshare, Deangelo Williams is not a 1 year wonder like many people think. He was a beast in college and a beast in his first real chance to play in the NFL- a poor man's LT. but i think its just a matter of time before McFadden takes over the Oakland job for good. McFadden is a special talent and showed it the only game he was healthy last year. In a redraft league, id probably still take Stewart, but in a dynasty i like Mcfadden. Only the immediate payoff and extra draft pick would sway me to trade for Stewart.

No one said Jstew would take over DeAngelo, I think what your referring to meant DeAngelo would be else where.

I like them both. I see Jstew with the upside of DeAngelo last year. But I also like McFadden's upside with the addition of DHB and Lorenzo Neal. That's what makes it tough for me. Neal is one of the best blocking FB's ever and as quite a resume,

Just a little of my mind I'd add to the bit.

Dynasty I'd take Jstew no question.

[TruNinerFan]

i disagree with earlier posters. I dont think Stewart will ever overtake Deangelo as the #1 and will always be stuck in a timeshare, Deangelo Williams is not a 1 year wonder like many people think. He was a beast in college and a beast in his first real chance to play in the NFL- a poor man's LT. but i think its just a matter of time before McFadden takes over the Oakland job for good. McFadden is a special talent and showed it the only game he was healthy last year. In a redraft league, id probably still take Stewart, but in a dynasty i like Mcfadden. Only the immediate payoff and extra draft pick would sway me to trade for Stewart.

Last year McFadden had a big game against the Chiefs who had one of the worst run defenses I have ever seen. Besides that, he didn't rush for over 50 yards in a game. McFadden is in a terrible sitatuation in Oakland and he is going to be stuck in an ugly RBBC with Fargas and M. Bush. I truly believe that M. Bush is the best RB on the Raiders roster and he will get his fair share of carries this year.

[LegendoftheFall]

Maybe im biased from watching McFadden alot in college. And admittedly Oakland is a train-wreck, but im saying longterm, i think McFadden will have a better career than JStew. Assuming Oakland can get some stability.