2 dynasty trade, help me choose please...

[irish158]

12 team dynasty with a 3 rd rookie draft. I took this team over this year and it need overhauling. I offered Rivers for Palmer and his 1.5, he countered me and I can choose either.
Trade 1- Rivers for his Palmer and 2.5
Trade 2- Rivers and 2.1 for Pamer and 1.5

My team:
QB Rivers, Garcia
RB Westbrook, C WIlliams, E James
WR Edwards, S Moss, Chambers, B Johnson, McDonald, Burress
TE Scheffler, Watson
K Akers, Kaeding
D Baltimore, NYG

WHIR if you want. Thank to all who help.

[TruNinerFan]

I would take trade 2. Palmer is a downgrade from Rivers, but I still think that Palmer is a top 10 QB if healthy. You need young talent bad and you will be able to get that guy with the 5th pick. Take whoever is left from Moreno, Wells, D. Brown, McCoy and Crabtree

[bungle613]

Deal 1 does you no good so pass. Deal 2 is ok. I think you can squeeze a bit more from him. I would counter with deal 2 but add a round 3 upgrade, without knowing specifics... if he has 3.05 and you have 3.12, swap them. It shouldn't be a deal breaker for him and may help you out. You need to take some fliers on rookies.

I assume you have to carry 2 at each position? If not, make sure you drop your TE2, K2 and DST2 and get some fliers on your bench.