Would you do this trade? WHIR!

[Metsown]

12 team ESPN PPR league, QB's only get 4 points per TD pass, the rest of the points are normal.

I get Donavon McNabb, Antonio Bryant, LeSean McCoy, and Tony Scheffler(or Dustin Keller)
for
Carson Palmer, TJ Houshmanzadeh, and Knowshon Moreno(although I'm trying to convince him to take Donald Brown instead...probably won't happen though)

My roster is:
QB(1): Palmer, Cambell
RB(2): Westbrook, Slaton, Moreno, Brown
WR(3): Bowe, Housh, VJax, Avery, Ginn Jr., Harvin, Mike Walker
TE(1): Shockey
D/ST(1): Chargers
K: Akers

Thoughts? whir

[thriftyrocker]

Moreno >>>>> McCoy (and Brown >>> McCoy)

TJH >> Bryant

Palmer < McNabb

Scheffler is not much better than the TE you have

I would not do any deal where the biggest improvement is TE depth.

If you are thinking "cuff Westbrook" I don't like that strategy. If it is one backup for another, e.g., picking between Greene and McCoy, ok. But Moreno is a starter from day one.

You need to get an elite WR out of him to make it worthwhile. Bryant is not elite because he is a headcase and TB will not pass as much.

[ninremix]

I would stay with what you have

[Metsown]

What about just Mcnabb and Bryant for Housh and Palmer?

[bungle613]

What about just Mcnabb and Bryant for Housh and Palmer?

You don't really have the WR depth to pull of this deal. While I believe McNabb will outpoint Palmer this year I don't think it will be by a huge amount. Stick with what you have but I would try and get a better QB2... not a Campball fan.

[Metsown]

How about Eddie Royal instead of Bryant? In a PPR Royal seems good...but I don't know...

[mattUTD20]

I think you should stay put.

[jmkratt]

I would also stay put, I like your squad.

Royal is attractive, I agree, though I think you'd be getting the short end of the deal for sure.

Any help?
viewtopic.php?t=439109

[thebigsmooth]

Not a chance.

I think you have much more upside on your team. Stay put.


Please take a look at mine
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=439149