Palmer/cassell/ e manning/ gerrad / edwards??

[goofus]

Im in a 16 man league...i pick 14th. i have

steve slaton
derrick ward
greg jennings
kellen winslow
patrick willis

there has been a run on qb's...palmer,cassel, e manning, gerrard, and edwards are the only ones really left worth a pick this early. im leaning toward palmer or cassell. any advice on the two? also the two rooks are left...strafford, and sanchez.

[lugmetric]

i like carson palmer a lot this year. no reason he can't be a top10 QB. i'd put him a whole tier above the rest of the guys you mentioned.

of cassel, garrard, manning, and edwards, i've got them:

cassel*
edwards
garrard
manning

*i have this weird feeling that he might lose his job by the end of the season, but as long as he's playing, his team will be behind, and he'll be throwing. a lot. against some suspect defenses 6 times a year.

[TruNinerFan]

I would go with Palmer. if healthy, I see him as a top 10 QB.

[goofus]

thanks...i think i will go with palmer...i was leaning that way anyhow. makes sense.