M.Forte for A.Johnson trade

[Mathew11.]

12 team
Keeper
PPR
1 year of the keeper league

MY TEAM:
QB: Phillip Rivers
WR: Gregg Jennings, Reggie Wayne
RB: Matt Forte, Kevin Smith
TE: Owen Daniels
W/T/R: Pierre Thomas
BN: Shaun Hill, Kevin Walter, Mark Clayton, Sammy Morris, Justin Fargas and Kevin Boss
K: David Akers
DEF: Minnesota

HIS TEAM:
QB: Ben Rothlesburger
WR: Andre Johnson, Wes Welker
RB: Steve Slaton, Darren mcfadden
TE: Chris Cooley
W/T/R: Ray Rice
BN: Joe Flacco, Joseph Addai, Donald Brown, Plaxico Burress, Purcy Harvin, and jeremy Cotchery
K:Rian Lindell
DEF: Tennesee

Now he sent me a offer thats like this...

I GIVE: Matt Forte and Justin Fargas
I GET: Andre Johnson and Dareen McFadden

If i accept ill have Smith and thomas as RB and 3 top WR cuz i can put Andre johnson on the W/T/R slot.

Now i told him if there's a way i can get Slaton in the deal and if Johnson cant be in the deal then ill take Welker insted.


Do i take the deal or recounter???

IF I RE COUNTER CAN U HELP ME WITH THE PROPOSAL
TYVM GUYS

[da bears]

I would actually take that trade and I love Forte. Between Smith, Thomas, and McFadden you will be able to toss 2 RB's out there that should be productive. In the PPR those WR's will win you plenty of weeks.

[Dawinner127]

I wouldn't. You don't need to make this trade. You already have two of the top five WRs in Jennings and Wayne.

[spider321]

Don't do it. Bad trade for you.

[lugmetric]

in a 12 team PPR keeper, forte is essentially untradeable. team is good the way it is.

[GameOver]

Yeah no way do I do that trade, you don't even know what to expect from Mcfadden anyways..

[Dan Lambskin]

no deal...

[Lightzout36]

agree with the rest. No deal.

I do not think there is anyway you can work Slaton into that trade. He obviously is looking to pair Slaton with Forte and have a dominate RB duo. Not to mention Wes is going to be a great PPR WR. I think this trade helps him more than you. I would not do this.