Trade Help.

[mgonz]

QB Matt Hasselbeck
QB Matt Schaub
WR Greg Jennings
WR T.J. Houshmandzadeh
WR Kevin Curtis
WR Josh Morgan
WR Michael Crabtree
RB Chester Taylor
RB Michael Turner
RB Frank Gore
RB Kevin Smith
RB Derrick Ward
TE Jeremy Shockey

Hey guys this is my team in a standard scoring 12 person league. One of the other managers is lacking in running backs and wants to give me Jerricho Cotchery for Kevin Smith or Derrick Ward. I don't think this sounds like a very good deal at all, but I wanted to see what everyone else has to say. Also would Frank Gore for Roddy White be a bad deal. Any info would help. Thanks alot

[Dan Lambskin]

what are your starting requirements and scoring?

until i know that i would say no to this deal as Ward and Smith are worth more than Cotchery, same with Gore over White...but it does appear you need some WR help...maybe see if you can move Smith for White?

[mgonz]

4pts for qb touch
1pt / 10 yds WR/RB
Non-PPR
Can Start WR or RB at flex.
I was thinking about offering him Housh and Kevin Smith for White. Think that would be overpaying?

[Dan Lambskin]

4pts for qb touch
1pt / 10 yds WR/RB
Non-PPR
Can Start WR or RB at flex.
I was thinking about offering him Housh and Kevin Smith for White. Think that would be overpaying?

yeah i think that is overpaying...i think you are OK starting starting
RB1 - Turner
RB2 - Gore
WR 1- Jennings
WR 2 - Housh
FLEX - Kevin Smith

[Dawinner127]

4pts for qb touch
1pt / 10 yds WR/RB
Non-PPR
Can Start WR or RB at flex.
I was thinking about offering him Housh and Kevin Smith for White. Think that would be overpaying?

yeah i think that is overpaying...i think you are OK starting starting
RB1 - Turner
RB2 - Gore
WR 1- Jennings
WR 2 - Housh
FLEX - Kevin Smith

Agreed. I think you are okay starting those, but the depth is a little weak IMO. Try and move Ward or Smith for a WR2 or see if you want to make a big deal and move Gore for a top tier WR.