Jennings, White, Knowshawn. Rate them in a keeper? WHIR

[vykeengfan]

10 team 3 keeper, PLUS a rookie we can keep from this year forever that will not count as one of our 3 keepers.
I have the 3rd and 5th picks in the first round. I don't have another pick until the 4th, where I have a mid and late round pick. My current keepers are Brady, Moss, and Portis. I think Jennings, White and Knowshawn will be available. How would you rank them, taking in to account that rookie keeper?
Standard scoring plus .5 ppr.
All replies appreciated and WHIR!!!

*EDIT*
We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 FLEX(rb/wr/te), 1 K, 1 DEF

[coolgoose]

What are the playing positions ?

Is Forte gone? for PPR he cud b gr8 value. Also Gore.
Otherwise Jennings is a great choice...so is white.

For Rookies - Moreno is good. U can track Wells, Brown, LeSean as well. Though Moreno would have possibly the earliest impact after Wells (if wells stays healthy ie).

[vykeengfan]

What are the playing positions ?

Is Forte gone? for PPR he cud b gr8 value. Also Gore.
Otherwise Jennings is a great choice...so is white.

For Rookies - Moreno is good. U can track Wells, Brown, LeSean as well. Though Moreno would have possibly the earliest impact after Wells (if wells stays healthy ie).

thx for the input, goose. forte and gore are kept. I guess what my question should be "should i take knowshawn before jennings, white, or both, if that was the situation?"

[coolgoose]

Well If I were you....I would grab Jennings before getting a Rookie. Moreno finally signed a contract and Wells is still injured.

I would rather keep studs in my team and try to trade mid-season with a low performing team for his rookie than gamble on present season.

I think by midseason Jennings will still be able to get u a good rookie and a decent replacement, but a rookie probably wont get u a Jennings.

Its a tough call...but thats just my opinion.