12 team PPR Keeper - Who to keep...WHIR!

[makimaki]

Keep 3: H2H PPR 12 team, Start 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 Flex, 1 TE, 1K, 1 DEF/S, 5 Bench

25 yards passing = 1pt, 10 yards rush = 1 pt, 15 yards receiving = 1 pt, 1 reception = 1 pt.

QB: McNabb, S. Hill
WR: White, Wayne, Boldin, Walter
RB: Portis, C. Johnson, Lynch, F. Jackson, Betts
TE: Z. Miller, Davis
K: Bryant
DEF: Steelers

We keep 3 but can only keep a max of 2 at any position. Leave a link!

[rashan]

Are all TDs=6? If so, then you need to wait a bit and see if most other top QBs are being kept.
Assuming passing TDs=4 or QBs are not being kept by other teams, then I'd keep these guys:
Johnson, Portis and White.

Help me too? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=439675

[Dawinner127]

Johnson, White, Wayne. Then see if you can land a RB2 with your first pick in the first round.

[makimaki]

Sorry for not providing that info. TD's are 6 points each. It looks like the big 3 (Manning, Brady, Brees) are going to be kept but there should be an abundance of talent out there left to draft. I'm fairly certain that I'm keeping White and Johnson but it's Portis that I keep going back and forth on. Like many others I wonder if this is the year he finally breaks down after having so much wear and tear over the years.

[Dawinner127]

Sorry for not providing that info. TD's are 6 points each. It looks like the big 3 (Manning, Brady, Brees) are going to be kept but there should be an abundance of talent out there left to draft. I'm fairly certain that I'm keeping White and Johnson but it's Portis that I keep going back and forth on. Like many others I wonder if this is the year he finally breaks down after having so much wear and tear over the years.

Go with the WRs. I think you can land a top tier RB to pair along with Johnson with your first pick in the first round.

[TruNinerFan]

C. Johnson, Boldin, Wayne

[Indibuck]

I like Johnson, Wayne, and Boldin.

[Egg2828]

QB: McNabb, S. Hill
WR: White, Wayne, Boldin, Walter
RB: Portis, C. Johnson, Lynch, F. Jackson, Betts
TE: Z. Miller, Davis
K: Bryant
DEF: Steelers


Ok keep 3, 2max per position. Do you keep these guys forever or 1yr 2yr?
WR:White: Young, Stud
WR:Wayne Top 5 WR and PPR Monster!!!!
RB: C.J (young, L.White is gone next year, ppr huge!)
Pass on Portis, over 300 carries just about every year, not near as much up side as CJ.

[makimaki]

We keep them as long as we want. Do you guys think that Wayne and Boldin are interchangeable? In my league last year Wayne finished with 2 more points than Boldin and Boldin was out a few games as we all know. I know that Fitz has finally become the receiver that everyone thought he would be but Boldin will still see the ball a lot. I suppose this isn't a bad problem to have!

[psmvchaser]

My order would be:
Johnson, White, Boldin, Wayne, Portis.

I like Boldin over Wayne. The whole Indy offense is getting stale and figured out.