Is Peterson that much better than Turner?

[nigel]

12 team Keeper league, 5 keepers. no PPR. So far I keep Turner, R. Brown, R. Bush, Edwards and Marshall. I can swap Turner and Bush for Peterson. then my keepers would be Peterson, Brown Edwards Marshall and maybe Mendenhall or Pat Willis (yeah, it is IDP) Shoud I stay or shoud I go for it ?

[Motown Blues]

Is Peterson that much better than Turner?

YES.

I can swap Turner and Bush for Peterson....Shoud I stay or shoud I go for it ?

YES.

[Egg2828]

Yes he is: Very young, and the best out there in none PPR league. HUGE O-Line and run 1st team, no passing game.

But to give up Turner and a RB3 in Bush i'm not sure. I think Bush is junk and after this year with PT who knows the value.

Since you have R.Brown I do the trade. That gets you a the best RB for years to come and a top notch #2RB in brown. Now go after Moreno,Wells,McCoy,D.Brown in your draft.


Good luck

[nigel]

[quote="Egg2828"]Yes he is: Very young, and the best out there in none PPR league. HUGE O-Line and run 1st team, no passing game.

But to give up Turner and a RB3 in Bush i'm not sure. I think Bush is junk and after this year with PT who knows the value.

Since you have R.Brown I do the trade. That gets you a the best RB for years to come and a top notch #2RB in brown. Now go after Moreno,Wells,McCoy,D.Brown in your draft.


Good luck[/quote]


thanks for your help.

the thing is that there are rankings where Bush is 16th overall http://www.luckylester.com/2009/04/dyna ... -football/

btw. I forgot mention that we start 2RBs and 1 flex, so I need 3 good RBs every week. Does it change anything?

[Cowboys 4 life]

Bush is already hurt again. I think Pierre ends up being the guy this year in NO. Bush's days are numbered.

I would do the trade. There will still be guys available that can start for you.

[Egg2828]

I have bush as a #3RB and his knee is hurt again. I avoid at all cost!

The reason I do the trade is because you get a top notch #1 and stil R.Brown. You can draft a #3 RB just as good as Bush but more upside like Moreno,Ward,FWP,LJ.


What RB"s are going back in your draft?

[nigel]

[quote="Egg2828"]I have bush as a #3RB and his knee is hurt again. I avoid at all cost!

The reason I do the trade is because you get a top notch #1 and stil R.Brown. You can draft a #3 RB just as good as Bush but more upside like Moreno,Ward,FWP,LJ.


What RB"s are going back in your draft?[/quote]


Not everyone posted their keepers yet, but I assume, beside rookies, ther wil be Lendale White (gone before pick, I think), Jamal Lewis, Felix jones, Benson, J.Jones, Sproles and Ravens backfield.
Everyone keeps QB, it seems. One guy keep !ELI! Manning and Matt Schaub. Only QB I´d draft in first half would be Carson Palmer.