Keeper Help!

[camurphree]

Hello.........I need help picking my three keepers for this year. There are 12 teams in my league. We are a PPR league and we start 1 QB, 6 flex, 3 Def. flex, and a K. I am drafting at the 10 position in a serpentine draft. The players I am choosing from are:

P. Manning
A. Peterson
F. Gore
DeA. Williams
P. Thomas
T. Jones

Thanks in advance for the help!

[kirmdaddy]

Petersen, seems like a no-brainer!

Who should I keep? I pick 11th in the 1st round, 22nd in 2nd, then snake draft. I am deciding between:

Clinton Portis WAS
Larry Johnson KC
Andre Johnson HOU
Philip Rivers SD


I am leaning towards Andre Johnson, I am thinking he will have a monster year ...

[hanny2042]

Peterson and Manning are definites in my opinion. Then it comes down to Gore or Williams to me. Even though I like Williams' talent, the committee approach may hurt him slightly with Stewart and Goodson (although it didn't at all last season, it's still a possibility). Gore has been very consistent and durable the last 3 years or so and with the addition of Coffee, he will hopefully get a few breaks and be more fresh and explosive. While I think they are very comparable, the kicker for me is that it is a PPR league. I don't know the exact numbers from last season, but I know that he has caught over 50 balls on more than one occasion.

Good keeper list there.