Colston, Berrian and Mendenhall for Smith (CAR) and Moore?

[UM_Wolverines19]

Would you trade colston berrian and mendenhall for smith and moore?

Heres my roster (standard ESPN scoring):

QB: McNabb
RB: Slaton, P. Thomas, Stewart, D. Brown, McCoy, Mendenhall
WR: Fitz, Colston, Berrian, Holt, Hixon
TE: Gates
DST: Eagles, Chargers
K: Elam

[Indibuck]

Nope

[dblj9911]

I would have to say no, you are trading the # 1 wr in the most potent offense in Colston, the # 1 wr in a quality Minny offense in Berrian and a rb who could be the starter with (or when) Parker goes down. So you are trading that for Smith, who should put up pretty similar numbers to Colsotn and Moore (I'm assuming Lance) who is the # 2, possibly 3rd or 4th option in NO (Shockey, R. Bush). I'm not making this move, stick with what you have. I'm also assuming that this is a redraft league as well.

viewtopic.php?t=441205